Massacra I have always use mascara and I Iove to try this always new brnwd mascara becuase it's make my eye look prey 😎.

Revlon liquid eyeliner This is absolutely my favorite liquid eyeliner! It glides on so well and doesn't smudge. It also stays on your eyes for the whole day with no need to reapply. I even used this before on my daughter for an Egyptian themed costume and it stayed on her all day and night through play and sweat! I highly recommend this!

Good price for good product Great eyeliner, stays in place, easy to use, doesn't run and is a great price. I'll definitely buy it again!

Best eyeliner One of my favorite eyeliners, doesn't smudge and stays on well even the non waterproof formula. It doesn't get crumbly either when you clean up your winged liner! Would highly recommend

Perfect cateye One of my favorite eyeliners aver, no smudge, nostreaks and great coverage. I keep a couple. Perfect for making great cat eyes.Easy to use and stays on all day or evening.

Get or Die Liner Amazing liquid eyeliner and I have been using it almost daily for years. I have never had an issue with this liner smudging or flaking. I am to remove it easily with makeup removal wipes and cleanser after 14+ hr days. The felt tip is great. The only con to me is when this liner gets low, it becomes very blotchy.

I have been using this eyeliner for years and wouldn't be tempted to trade. Although it is not waterproof, it is long-lasting. My favorite feature is actually that the applicator is more of a felt tip than a brush, allowing for a lot of control when applying the makeup.

Great quality and great price.

I love liquid eyeliner. I wear it everyday. This eyeliner is easy to use and cheaper than most brands.

I do love the product, but my only problem with it is that when I put re-wetting drops in my eyes, it runs. I wear contacts and some products don't hold up to having to keep them moisturized and having dry eyes.

it runs....but its ok

Love it, stays on all day no flaking and great price

stays on and goes on smooth

i love it because it last all day and doesn't smudge.

After the days ended it starts flaming a little bit. But everything else about it is good.