I've had this eyeliner for some time now but I don't ever use it. It's just too runny/ watered down.

I really wanted to like this but it just wasn't a quality item for me. I want my eyeliner to go on cleanly, smoothly, and cling there like its life depends on it. I've found that Smashbox waterproof gel liners (used with their flat brush or any quality flat brush) do just that, and they won't budge. You can fall asleep face-first into your pillow and that gel eyeliner will STILL be where you left it the night before. Not under your eyes, in your eyes, on your pillowcase, but RIGHT SMACK there on your lids! You can even line inside your eye with it.

I purchased this because the price was great and the brand is preferred but it is WAY to runny

Easy to apply and great color, but it doesn't last and it doesn't look exactly natural.

Loved this eyeliner the first couple of times I used it but then the cheaply made brush started falling apart and make it very hard to apply. I wouldn't recommend this because of the applicator.

i was not at all amused it. thought it was me but after speaking to other ppl they agree it isnt the best bang for my $$.. i did however love the elf pen liner. so easy to apply. doesnt flake and last a long time. For a dollar cant be beat!

I do like the price and I like that it didn't make me cry like most others, but they really need to make it less runny. It's very hard to work with, I use only this style applicator - more like a sharpie style brush and i love that they did that as well but again the actual eyeliner is very runny. Sorry not the best I've used.

I expect covergirl to bring it because this is a competitive market but I am very disapointed with this product. This eyeliner should have never left the lab.

Because I use Colorstay foundation & love it, I decided to try the colorstay eyeliner. IT stays on alright... but it seemed to make my eyes burn (I just line my top lid, never the bottom) and my eyes arent even sensitive. By the end of the work day my eyes were so red I looked either high or drunk-- just partied out!!! So now it just sits around in my makeup bag.. maybe I'll try it again, if its not dried up by now lol..

Its ok I guess. Product has a tendency to be a little harder to apply a thin line

Not my preference

Like most of these little gel pot liners, the product dries too quickly and often cracks and smudges. very unfortunate.

I don't like that this eyeliner seems to begin flaking off by the end of the day. I do like how easily it goes on.

It's not bad but seems to always get into my eyes before it sets. Perhaps if it were a little thicker it would be easier but then it also seems to flake after a few hours of wear .

This eyeliner is not terrible, but it is not necessarily good. It's okay if you need to buy a last minute drug store eyeliner, but I would not recommend it for everyday use. It does tend to smudge throughout half of the day.