I thought they would be more "cakey" - but aside from some pastel confetti in the cream, they weren't much different from normal Oreos.

The taste of these Oreos could had been better. I didn't taste much birthday cake flavor in them. Also, the packaging is too small for me to buy all the time. If the company wants to make any type of profit off these, they should really consider to bring out a better tasting kind and a bigger package. The price, on sale or not, is not really that attractive with how small the packaging is. I am currently undecided on whether or not to recommend these to anyone.

I like theses

can't really taste the birthday cake, but the oreo is just as good as the regular!

i love oreo cookies but i find the filling soooo sweet! i would sometiomes just eat the cookie itself minus the overly sweet filling :(

they definitely have a birthday cake taste and they are on the overly sweet side, but eating just one or two makes it a nice treat. I thought they were delicious, I just had to eat them in moderation because of their sweetness

On the positive side, the Oreo Birthday Cake is convenient and cost less than ice cream cakes from Dairy Queen. I wasn't crazy about the taste, a little artificial flavor after taste. For a quick easy birthday treat, I say go for it. If your looking for decadent ... you may want to try something else.

I found these limited time only Birthday Cake Oreos at one of our local grocery stores and my friends and I thought they were yummy! If you like make at home 'boxed cakes with container frosting', you will like these cookies.

Two of my favorites Honestly I haven't tried these yet, but they sound amazing. I love Oreos and I love birthday cake. Can't wait to try these.

Great snack

I liked these cookies. They aren't as good as the original in my opinion but they have a good flavor.

tried these once and really liked them and then couldnt find them anywhere after that haha

These cookies were good but I couldn't eat that many at a time. The smell of them is really strong.

Cookies that taste like cake great concept. Great cookie

What a great addition to the Oreo line of cookies! These taste just like a cake - perhaps a little on the sweet side. I do prefer the original Orea's, but do like these ones too!