On the positive side, the Oreo Birthday Cake is convenient and cost less than ice cream cakes from Dairy Queen. I wasn't crazy about the taste, a little artificial flavor after taste. For a quick easy birthday treat, I say go for it. If your looking for decadent ... you may want to try something else.

I found these limited time only Birthday Cake Oreos at one of our local grocery stores and my friends and I thought they were yummy! If you like make at home 'boxed cakes with container frosting', you will like these cookies.

Great snack

These cookies were good but I couldn't eat that many at a time. The smell of them is really strong.

perfect sweeet treat to curb that sugar craving! Tall cold glass of milk and a handfull of Birthday Cake Oreos. Heaven. ......

These are a fun alternative flavor to the plain Oreo! The taste is a very good cake flavor, and the sprinkles are fun! The taste is very sweet- but I think that helps a bit to curb the feelings of eating too many! Definitely not as good as the original, but a fun flavor to try it to buy for a special occasion.

every kind of oreo are amazing and this one takes the cake!! LOL!!! these cookies rock!! YUMMY!!! gotta love 'em!!

What a great addition to the Oreo line of cookies! These taste just like a cake - perhaps a little on the sweet side. I do prefer the original Orea's, but do like these ones too!

These were amazing! But they were pretty sweet.

Cookies that taste like cake great concept. Great cookie

they definitely have a birthday cake taste and they are on the overly sweet side, but eating just one or two makes it a nice treat. I thought they were delicious, I just had to eat them in moderation because of their sweetness

tried these once and really liked them and then couldnt find them anywhere after that haha

I liked these cookies. They aren't as good as the original in my opinion but they have a good flavor.

i love oreo cookies but i find the filling soooo sweet! i would sometiomes just eat the cookie itself minus the overly sweet filling :(

Okay, but not the best It's an ok Oreo, but if you really want a birthday cake Oreo, go for the one that is the white cookie birthday cake Oreo.