Not bad, but not the best I have tried. Good color and not too pricy

I have never used it, but my granddaughter tells me it is really great.

Pigmented I used to use this many many years ago and of course I had to have every color...It applied creamy and was really pigmented especially the black,brownn and blue shades! Just some colors were a little waxy and I had to apply a few times to achieve a bold line...

I completely agree with pederzani's comments. I'm a big fan of Bobbi Brown but gave this a shot (thank you ladies at makeupalley.com). I use my MAC brush because the one provided is just too harsh but otherwise it's a great product (especially for the money).

Try Kmart...it was 50% off...get a deal! I bought it in black and purple and I love them both. The little brush it comes with is not that bad either :-)

I've always kind of used this for my go-to cat eyeliner and its so amazing, creamy, and doesn't dry out....the brush is ok, if you don't have an alternative its not going to be terrible to use, and i even alternate between this brush and others that i own so it is good...wet n wild has hits and misses..this is a hit ^.^...their new matte lipsticks are also really good!...maybe i'll do a review on them lol

I really like this product. It can be a bit messy if you dont know how to apply it correctly. I wish the brush was a bit thinner.

I love this for top liner. Whenever I tried it for my water line it made my eyes really irritated and ran. Its probably just my eyes though because I have really bad allergies. it stays all day and even longer when I wear it as top liner though. I have recommended this to so many people in the past and many of them say that they can not find it anymore. I'm not sure if it just sold out in my area or if it is discontinued. I hope its not, I've had mine too long and it's starting to dry out. I need another one.

I love this liner, it goes on smooth and the color is amazing, 5*

I LOVEET N" WILD!!!! It is so cheap, and long-lasting! I haven't tired this product yet, (Sorry, I don't know how to post a commment without the stars) but I'll be sure to look into it! :)

Love it. Very comparable to MAC's fluidline in Blacktrack. However it doesn't stay on the waterline like MAC's does, but at this price it's not an issue. Definitely better than costalscents gel liner, but dont get me started on CS liner... A must for budget make up collections!

Great product, affordable and nice quality. Very dark black color and doesn't smudge.

I think this product is fantastic! I did a comparison of the Wet n Wild Creme Eyeliner with MAC's Fluidline in Blacktrack and the results were astonishing. The Fluidline, which runs for about $16-$18, smears easily and has very little staying power, whereas the Creme Eyeliner lasted all day without fading away. I also love that this product is such a bargain! You also end up with more product with the Wet n Wild than you do with the MAC. I only have two minor issues with this product: 1) the brush it comes with isn't the greatest, but that's easily fixed and 2) the product is made in China. My only reluctance with using a product made in China, on my skin and that close to my eyes is the possibility of one day discovering that it was manufactured with a little something extra in it that could quite possibly affect me. If you can look past these issues, you're making a great investment with this product.

i have so many of these i absolutly love these they are amazing the only thing i dont like is that if you dont use them alot they will dry up on you

i love this product so much