Invest in a better eyeliner Goes on sheer and feels very greasy. Would not recommend.

Good for the price I have to say the packaging for this eyeliner is deceiving in the way that it feels more high end but it's really cheap! The eyeliner is OK I was not wowed by it but it got the job done. The brush was OK but wore out really quickly but, hey just buy a new one since they're so cheap! Itso not a product I would reach for everyday but, I would definitely recommend to someone looking for a good liner.

price is up there but it works !

Love cream eyeliner I rather the cream eye liner over liquid after I tried it and was able to apply it better than liquid. The only issue I have is the brush gets hard after u use it due to eyeliner on it.

For the price - it's great! Although this eyeliner is fairly cheap - it's a really good product. Black, goes on very smoothly and lasts. However, if you have oily lids you may want to steer clear.

My favorite cream eyeliner. It lasts all day and feels amazing. The price is affordable as well.

This is a great alternative to more expensive brands. I bring this,one with me whenever I travel or in my purse. Works great and the price can't be beat.

Love this eyeliner! So smooth and lasts all day with a rich black color. I use it with an angled eye line brush Does seem to dry out quicker than others, but I add a little water to the brush and it helps it last longer. Love the price too! $3

I love this product it's better than some of the pricier one's it lasts a long time but dries out quickly!

I like this liner and I buy it frequently. However, beware, it dries out quickly. It's cheap though and works great so I say it's worth buying!

True to its color. Stays on for a long time.

they should call this a tatoo i swear!!! it literally stays on all day!!!! and it isnt that hard to apply on especially when u take the time to master it

I absolutely loved my E.L.F. cream liner in black. I used it on a daily basis. It glides so smoothly making application time very short! I've had at least three containers of these. Unfortunately I've had so many because they dried out so quickly. I'm not sure if whatever they use in the formulation dries quickly or the jars don't have a great seal, but if they would fix this it would be 5 stars for me.

I love this eyeliner, but I had to give it 4 stars because I have purchased them in 3 colors, and only the black was good. The golden was actually a LIME GREEN color and the white was not pigmented at all. However, I'm completely in love with the black cream eyeliner and I use it whenever I want a dramatic wing or whenever I put eyeliner above my top lashes.

Great