it's drys up I have to keep applying it . It makes my eyes it by an it smudges

It's OK but I am partial to the pencil it never fails me.

I find that the eyeliner dries out pretty quickly and that's disappointing.

I was always using the felt tipped eyeliners and my cousin gifted me this one. I reluctantly used this one day and was pleasantly surprised. I mean its not as easy as a felt tip eyeliner to apply, but it really is pretty and looks very put together. Can play with diff variations like winged or heavy look. It smudges a little bit but I guess it is the problem with every liquid eyeliner.

This does the job, but it dries out too soon, abd for around $10 -not necessarily the best, but not the worst.

easy to apply but needs a touchup around 5pm to look fresh for a night out

I love that is dosent smudge, but i have i bit trubble with paintig it on :-(

I am very indifferent about this product. The color is extremely vibrant and goes on smoothly in the beginning but after a few applications it starts to get dull and dry. I'm not a fan of having to replace the same product to often. The container is noticeably smaller than other eyeliners I've used which made me hesitate on buying. In the end. I rate 3 stars. Not the worst not winning a grammy

It's Long lasting, but once a tear or sweat touches the liner it will smudge.

It smudges very easily, and gets kind of lumpy after a while, but it's affordable and has easy application.

It's just ok for me. I find it a little messy. I like the pencil alot better.

Okay but not great This product is hard to use. You have to go very slow so you don't mess up. It lasts okay once you get it on but it could be easier to use.

Nexxxtttttt.. This color is nice but you only get a few good uses with it. It smudges after a couple of hours. If you're looking for a great find I honestly wouldn't recommend this eyeliner.

Too messy for me Even though brush is thinner I still have problems using liquid liner but I thought I woukd give it a try again during holidays but to no evail. When you do make a mistake its hard to correct without a mess.

I liked this eye liner. It went on thick and pigmented. Although I had a reaction and it made my eye lid a bit itchy and swollen. It did last for about four hours under a primer but then it began to smudge. It was easy to use with the applicator and was thin enough for control.