it makes your lashes voluminous, thick, and long, but it is not smudge-proof. 2 hours in and under my eye it is gray/black.

to clumpy I have very long eyelashes and like when mascara separates them and volumes them as well as makes them even longer. I found this mascara to be clumpy and the brush was way to think for my liking. I felt i couldn't get in the corners of my eyes to put product on those lashes. When i did it made a mess.

Not worth the hype Aside from it being a mediocre mascara at best, I think the price is too high. The mascara flakes off and leaves my eyes stinging after a day of wear.

Nope! I don't understand how this has a cult following. Flakes off, requires massive amounts of effort to remove, and it it didn't even make my lashes look fuller or longer. Save your money.