Nope! I don't understand how this has a cult following. Flakes off, requires massive amounts of effort to remove, and it it didn't even make my lashes look fuller or longer. Save your money.

Not worth the hype Aside from it being a mediocre mascara at best, I think the price is too high. The mascara flakes off and leaves my eyes stinging after a day of wear.

I know people love this mascara, but I dont get it. I found the applicator wand big and unnecessary. The mascara clumped easily. It was most definitely NOT better than sex.

it makes your lashes voluminous, thick, and long, but it is not smudge-proof. 2 hours in and under my eye it is gray/black.

Not for me. I dont like it. Its smudgey and clumpy. Its not worth the hype for me just a mess...

Not very good. Definitely not what I expected and not what it is Hyped up to be. Store brands are better.

It flakes like crazy! Love this mascara...they only flaw is that it flakes so bad, it is such a shame because I really love how my lashes looked.

to clumpy I have very long eyelashes and like when mascara separates them and volumes them as well as makes them even longer. I found this mascara to be clumpy and the brush was way to think for my liking. I felt i couldn't get in the corners of my eyes to put product on those lashes. When i did it made a mess.

Meh, mascara junkie and not a favorite from me This product isn?t that great, I don?t get the hype. Many better products that cost the same or less. Flakes, doesn?t add enough thickness or volume.

Works well for a natural look This is a very popular mascara, the it did not make my lashes long, or voluminous. It is great for those who already have thick and long lashes because it will give your lashes the right amount of effective. The color shows black, and is more dark than other mascaras.

not great not the best? i have used way better mascaras for the price.

Disappointed I loved this mascara for the first couple uses and it also didn't bother my sensitive eyes. However the product got very clumpy and became unusable after 4 or 5 uses.

Takes a lot of work to build up I wasn't super impressed with this mascara. It was very buildable, but not worth the price tag.

Disappointed I received this mascara as a gift from my sister. She loves this mascara and wanted me to try it. It did add some length and volume to my lashes, however, I found that my preferred mascara still outperformed this mascara. I'm surprised the price runs a lil higher when I can get better results with CoverGirl.

Can I get a spoolie after? I'm kinda in a love/hate relationship with this wand. Lol I just wish that it didn't clump up on me. My eyelashes are sparsish and this formula & wand is just too much.