Used this for the first time today, I really liked how it went on and that I was able to smudge it so that the line wasn't so defined. I also really like the chocolate color, I'm sure it will become a staple in my makeup bag!

This is a really great (*non waterproof*) brown eyeliner. I love how incredibly creamy it is and that I don't have to sharpen it. The smudger can be used to create a sultry look (smoky eye) or the smudger can be used to soften the appearance of the liner (just smudge more of it away). I also enjoy that it comes with two caps to cover each end of the liner. I've been looking for a great neutral brown liner--that isn't metallic--and the espresso liner is fantastic for this purpose. I use it on my lower and upper lash lines, but it works best on my upper lash line, since it's not waterproof. It did smudge under my eyes, but it was wonderful for my upper lash line liner! I'll keep using it for that :) Best qualities: It's creamy and doesn't tug on your eyes. The color is well-pigmented and neutral. I'd buy several more shades of these. Note: I received this one as a sample. This is my own honest opinion. Have a nice day!

For me is always easier to apply eyeliner when is a pencil, that's why I was so happy to received this eyeliner on my box. The shade is nice and easy to apply, perfect for someone like me who is not so good with makeup.

I am eye liner freak and love trying different ones for newer looks.This is my first time use of covergirl eye pencil. I love how the pencil is soft enough for smooth and easy application.It gave a very dark line kind of dramatic looking.I wore in it cold weather and didn't notice any smudging or fading of shade.It remains to try it in warm/hot weather.Overall it is a nice convenient product.

Great lasting product.

Liked the way it went on smoothly and didn't skip.

I got this eyeliner from SheSpeaks to try and I really love it. It is easy to apply and it doesn't smudge and comes off really easily.

so smooth and easy to use and it does last, I love this stuff and i think I am going to switch to this brand. It looks good and doesn't skip or run off.

worked well

I liked the way this went on, wasnt really my color as i prefer black, but overall great product

Very easy to use this eyeliner. I really like that it comes with a built in smudging tip.

This product was easy to apply, stayed where I wanted it, and really made my eyes stand out.

i like the color and it goes on very smooth but the color did not stay on all day.

This eyeliner is very easy to use. It glides on and has the perk of always being sharp. My one negative about this product is that it came off easily. I rubbed my eye one time and all of the product came off. It was still very easy to use!

Ok, I have to admit that I could not figure out how to get the pencil to roll up. I worked and worked, I read the package and it gave no clue about rolling it up. A little instuction would be great. I accidently made it roll out a little bit and was able to use it. I liked the line but I still have no clue about rolling it up.