Benefit They're Real! Mascara

Benefit They're Real! Mascara

              Rated #43 in Makeup - Eyes
Reviews Ratings
107 Reviews 4.5/5 stars
93% Recommended
Add a Review
  • 5
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1

Love this mascara one of my faves for sure. It does do what it says it does. I love how my eye lashes look it gives it volume and it separates my lashes. The only thing that I don't like about this mascara is if u apply a second coat your eye lashes can get clumpy.

This mascara is fantastic. It separates my lashes, adds major volume and length giving an intense falsies effect. I would definitely repurchase this once I run out. After being disappointed with Benefit's Bad Gal, I'm so glad I found this and Benefit you've restored my faith in your mascara line.

Applied very well, I had the black and it looked very good on my lashes, the reason that this gets 4/5 stars is because it chips off sometimes. Generally I really love this mascara though

I didn't realize how much I would actually love this mascara, until I was using it on a daily basis! It separates my lashes beautifully, and I love how black and bold this makes my eyelashes look, with little to no clumping and ZERO flaking! Personally, I can't say how lengthening this is because I have naturally long lashes, but this little gem is definitely worth a try!

I have tried a lot of mascaras, and so far this is the best. The plastic wand has rows and rows of little teeth to grab each lash and separate. It really does extend the look of my lashes. It does not flake or run. Removal is a bit tricky ..this product needs multiple removal, when you think it is off, you will see a smudge still under your eyes. But, the extra few minutes is worth using this product.

My favorite mascara! I love this product..everyone always compliments me on how long my eyelashes look and I love it! Just wish it was a little cheaper

I love this mascara! It made my lashes look amazing

Best mascara hands down. Trick is if you can apply mascara infront of a fan or AC in your car so it dries faster and reapply as you wish.

I absolutely love this mascara it really made my eyes POP.. i would recommend it to anyone who wants to take there makeup to the next level.

This is my favorite mascara. It is exceptionally easy to apply & always gives great results. It is easy to wash off at night as well. I can't say enough good things about it.

After reading all the hype I was very happy that for me this mascara has lived up to it. After a few applications I learned one coat is all that's needed or it can get clumpy. I have no problem removing it with soap and water but after getting rained on there was no raccoon eyes ! It does flake a bit during application but once applied I have no flaking if your looking for length and some thickening this is for you.


This mascara was amazing, not to pricy, and lasted a really long time.

I like the way this made my lashes look, but I don't like that it won't come off with my regular face wash. I had to use eye makeup remover which is an extra step for me.

I do like the wand on this mascara. I have small thin lashes and they are brought to life with this mascara. I wish it would make them longer as well as fuller.