If you're a fan of gel eyeliner, this is perfect for you. It is easy to smudge out to not be so dramatic, but stays put enough after awhile.

It doesn't dry out, and it usually stays on for hours. I'm not a big fan of the brush though, so I use it with my angled liner brush.

I love this and the brush it comes with! I do not find this useful to do a wing but I do like to do it for the initial line on the upper lash line as well as lining my lower water line. I do find it does tend to smudge on the lower lash line by the end of the day.

I love this product! It's super easy to achieve that retro cat eye look, which I tend to go for on special occasions. My only objection is that regardless of it's waterproof quality, wearing this liner on your lower lash line can make a bit of a smudgy mess, after a couple hours. I does, however, last a long time on your upper line and is relatively easy to remove.

Really loved this liner... the texture is great and it goes on easy.Just wish they provided you with a better brush to apply it. ended up using my own brush.

It?s not bad I like it because of the pigment and it stays in place all day

If I need some dramatic eyeliner to perfect that wonderful smokey eye look, this is what I reach for. It stays put for hours and hours. It's very easy to apply once you get the hang of it, as well. The brush would be a little more helpful if it had an angle to it, but I've had no problems using another eyeliner brush instead of the one that was included. It doesn't smudge, and it goes on bold and dark! It's not something I use every day because it takes a minute to apply it, but I know what to use when I need something I can count on. Overall, it's great. Just make sure you put the cap back on the jar and clean the brush regularly for best use.

I never understood why this product got so much love. At first, I thought it was an okay product. i wasn't really impressed after switching from Mac's fluidline so, I decided to try other brands. It wasn't until I tried other brands that I realized how awesome this product was. It was even BETTER than the fluidline that I onced loved. It doesn't dry out as quickly as the fluidline, it hardly smudges and the price is decent. What more can I say? I've only tried the black so far so, this review is specifically for the black liner. I'm sure the others are equally as awesome though.

Best eyeliners ever. Very creamy and easy to apply.The colors are amazing and stand out. Stays put, no cracks, no smudges.

A truly sensational liner. Long lasting, easy to apply with a super brush. It is easily comparable to the more expensive gel liners. I' m so thrilled my regular brand was not available and I gave this liner a try.

Awesome investment for a drugstore eyeliner! Goes on smooth and i like the brush too. Doesn't stink and this product lasts forever! I cant even remember when i bought mine, fall maybe? It looks like I've barely touched it! Very pleased.

like the smooth way it goes on & looks, easy to use

It's very dramatic so I only wear it on nights out, but I love it.

love how it makes my eyes pop, and it lasts long!

I would love to try this!