The color was not good. The cream eyeliner is supposed to be creamy at least, but mine was hard cream which made is much harder to apply to my eyes. Not smooth. I started using the elf cream eyeliner in black at it's way better than the Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner.

I bought this in a hurry mistaking it for one I had tried and loved but couldn't remember the name of at the time (ended up being loreal infallible lacquer liner). Lets just say it is still sitting in a drawer somewhere more or less untouched. The applicator/brush was too flimsy for an even application. I usually wear black when it comes to eyeliner and do a simple cat eye but the black for this product is more like a medium grey. I like my eyeliner to resemble liquid liner as much as possible without having to endure the struggle (me vs. liquid liner = complete and utter defeat on my end).

Not that impressed. I plan on just sticking with MAC. I was just hoping for a cheaper alternative. It didn't stay on as well and the color wasn't as vibrant.

It's okay, will not buy it again.

The texture of the eyeliner goes on super smooth! I have tried black and it is great! Very good at not smudging too bad, flaking off, or chipping off during the day. The brush lets you use just the tip or more of the brush to get thicker or thinner lines. Easy to put on bottom eyelid as well!

The black gel has a nice deep color for dramatic eyes, however, the eyeliner brush is too thick in my opinion. It makes it difficult to create a thin line. I have had to redo my entire eye from messing up the first time. Maybe it is just my fingers being a little unsteady, but I am going to be trying some other brand or at least using a different applicator with the product.

disappointed. i dont like the brush, it was too thick, and mine dried out instantly. im going to stick with my victorias secret gel liner.

I usually use a pencil liner, but I decided to try this product out. I started out loving it. Until about 3 weeks later. The gel liner started to dry out and the brush bristles started falling out. I think I may just stick with my faithful pencil liners.

I love that you control how much product you use & that it doesn't run everywhere like liquid eyeliner. I have a sensitivity to some cosmetics & this doesn't burn or bother my eyes. A huge downside of this eyeliner is it's extremely hard to get off. I use coconut oil, my facewash AND eye makeup remover & it still leaves traces behind.

The gel liner works evenly once you apply it. Do not let the product stand too long on the brush or else the bristle will get hard and it wont glide through when using it. Mine, did not last long because the gel liner dried up so fast. This would be great for first time users that would like to practice more on creating wing-eyeliner.

I think that this eyeliner is fantabulous! It stays in place like no ones business! It defiantly runs with some high end gel eyeliners. I am at school for most of the day and it STAYS in place. It may not be the best for the most precise line but it is so good I can look past that.! ;)

Really smooth, works good.

I would love to try this!

It's very dramatic so I only wear it on nights out, but I love it.

I bought this eyeliner. Then I kept repurchasing. This is a fantastic eyeliner, one of my favourites. I'm not currently using this eyeliner, as I am trying new ones, but this is literally such a great drugstore gel eyeliner. I've gotten a lot of friends and family to convert to this specific one!