I am sure this would have been a wonderful eyeliner, but the one I received didn't twist up. :( I was really bummed because I use their twist up eyeliner in black and love it. Would have loved to try the espresso brown I got and would have been cool to see how the self sharpening feature would have worked.

Liked at first but it smudged later in day

Don't love this one, I suppose it would be good if you are just starting with make-up. I prefer a liquid liner, this is fairly hard on the lid when you try to smooth it across.

uummm.. this was okay I really love the eyeliner I just wasn't loving the color.. if I had to try this in black I would be totally in love with it and guard it forever..lol.. but since I had brown I am going to say it was just okay

I liked the eyeliner, however, I was not impressed with the color. Maybe if I would've gotten a black sample, it would be a better experience.

I received the CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus eyeliner in my P&G box. I received the shade 210 Espresso. I really loved the color of the eyeliner, it is definitely neutral and will work with any eye color. I have green eyes, and a smoky dark brown like this definitely makes my eye color pop. The color was superb, the applicator twisted up without a problem, and the blender on the end is covered, which is important. Overall, this eye liner is mechanically sound. This eye liner is great if you only plan to use it for a couple of hours. Eye liner is a part of my every day look, and I felt that this eye liner was more for a quick show, than a long day. The eyeliner was definitely not water resistant. It lasted long, but melted off pretty quick even without heat or sweat and before I even had a chance to get oily. The line did not stay, even with a clean base. Although I prefer this color and applicator to other eyeliners, the staying power does not compare to my normal eye liner. (Smashbox limitless) I would recommend this to someone who likes a long lasting eye liner, but does not mind using a base AND a good setting with powder after applying it. I prefer a clean edgy look with eyeliner and the lines blur. For a strong stay put line I would give this 0 stars, but for a smoky smudgy look ... I would give this 5 stars so I am averaging it out to 3 overall.

I received this product to test out and I like the concept of it being self sharpening but I found that it wasn't as easy to apply and not a creamy smooth texture to allow it to glide on easily. It does have good staying power though.

I liked the fact that this liner lasted longer than others that I have tried. The only fault that I had was that it took to many swipes across the eye to get it to show up.

Decent liner and excellent price I've used this liner in the past, it is a good liner and I like the smudge tip for a smoky look!! I prefer a pencil liner honestly and a liquid pen for top lids

Not too bad i have too say, nice colors, stays well and the point is nice!!

I don't typically wear makeup, so I wasn't sure what to expect. It was easy to apply and went on smoothly, and it seemed to last all day. Seems like a great product!

love the color and how easy it is to use. Comparable to ones I've spent much more on.

I don't use these a lot but it works good from what experience I've had

I do not use eyeline pencils. But I tried it and I have to say I liked it. It was a lot easier to use than I imagined. It stayed on all day.

This liner was very easy to apply and stayed on all day. I love the smudging brush that is attached.