I actually really like this eyeliner. It's not waterproof and can smudge off, but it's easy to apply and great for those new to liquid liners. Just remember to shake it between eyes to re-wet the tip. It's a decent black and it does stay pretty well for the most part.

Amazing Love It, Better Than A Pencile Liner.

Really like the tip on this liner. Stayed on day! Definitely not as messy as other liquid liners I've used!

great eyeliner works wonders

i heard this product is great and i should buy it

I got it from my sister in law, I fell in love with it, I was using an expensive brand name that really wasn't that superior, I use it all the time.

cover girl things are always good

My FAVORITE eye liner. Lasts all day. Looks great when applied. Easy to get the look your going for with fineness of applicator brush. Fault. Brush gets frayed.

I love this product i would recomand this to anyone who is a begainer so please try it

I love this liner! I couldn't find the L'Oreal brand I normally buy in the right color so I tried this one. It is by far the easiest and best eye liner I've tried. I hate those pencils so I use liquid liners and this one is so easy. It's a little pen and it's great. It's even easy to correct mistakes if you do it before it's dry. I will not switch back to my old liner!

this is a great product with smooth aplication! go buy it!

This was a great eyeliner for a beginner in beauty world! Haha! I was one. I purchased this item with my own money for the first time and I was so glad I did. I always wanted to learn how to apply eye liner to my lash lines. This eyeliner did not have a flimsy tip instead it had a sturdy marker-like tip and it was so easy to glide across my lash lines with no skidding. It sometimes come off if you accidentally rub your eyes or if you cry. Haha at least it was a great liner for a beginner! I definitely recommend to a person who wants to learn how to do cat eyes but don't know how to use a eye liner, try this item. You won't regret it. I promise!

My daughter is very pleased with this type of liner

I totally bought this the other day. I usually buy almay liquid eyeliner, but the handle ends up broken after awhile... no good! this one is super easy to apply, fits anywhere, and is sturdy enough to handle my diaper bag/purse anytime! lol! i love it

I loved this product it comes really handy when you are in a hurry, because the tip of this liner makes it more simpler and faster to apply to your eyelid and gives you the choice to have a thin line or thick, unlike other liners.