is the first time I use this eyeliner covergirl, I loved it because it is easy to apply, it's like a crayon, paint my eyes very easily without having to spend several times. the only thing I liked is that it ends too fast.

This is my 2nd favorite eyeliner. Its perfect its smooth but not so smooth that it smudges everywhere and self sharpening perfect but I still dont prefer it over my Urban Decay eyeliner sorry, but still i was super excited when i saw it in my P&G Box.

I received a free sample from SheSpeaks to try and I liked it. Nice lines, easy to apply and lasts but I still prefer my liquid liner from Cover Girl.

easy to use. glides on smooth and simple. love the color too

Goes on nice, easy to apply. Did smudge a little more than I am used to.

It just glides on your eyelids. So easy to use and very affordable.

I really like this product and will definitely try again. I have been using the non-sharpen eyeliners that typically break, even when capped. I have not had this problem with this eyeliner. I do have to sharpen before every use though.

I have used covergirl eyeliners for years so i was happy when i received this too review. They go on smooth and have a nice point .Only thing i dont like is that it does start to smudge after a couple of hours.

I was so excited to get this eyeliner because I thought it was an eyebrow pencil, which I am in need of. I was a bit disappointed when I found out it was an espresso colored eyeliner--i am blonde and fair skinned so I honestly did not open it. I will probably give it to a friend and ask their feedback for this product reveiw site. Covergirl makes great products, so if this were blue or green to go with my tones I'd be happier. I certainly appreciate it being sent to me--it was fun to open the box.

I loved this--it went on smoothly with a good line, and stayed on all day. I will buy it for sure. My only issue was that this particular one quit twisting up after a couple of uses.

Great eyeliner. Easy to use, smooth line, and you can control how thick or thin you want to make the line. Nice addition.

I've been using this eyeliner for years and don't even think about trying another one. Mainly because I don't have to buy and use a separate tool, namely, a pencil sharpener. I love having it all in one. It glides on very smoothly and stays on for a long period of time. The only thing is that sometimes I've gotten some that don't twist up very good and I feel like I'm fighting to get the liner up. But I go back and buy again because it's still very good

Received this as a sample from P & G. Love the Expresso color! Goes well with my skin color and eye color - pale skin and green eyes. Like that it is self-sharpening and has a "smudger" on the end. I do have a little trouble getting it to apply smoothly on a consistent basis - a little "clumping" on rare occasions. But overall, I would definitely buy and recommend to my friends!!!

this liner goes on smoothly but by the end of the day it had sort of smudged and worn off....could be my eyelid type that causes this to happen

i normally do not wear eyeliner; i found this to be easier to apply than other brnads, it did not smear or run like other brnads after having the eyeliner on for a full day. it was a bit diffcult to wash off, at least for myself.