I am impressed!! It was smooth and did not pull or hurt my eye. Most of the time I avoid lining my eyes because I can't find a pencil that doesn't hurt or is too rough. But now, I think I found a winner!!!

is the first time I use this eyeliner covergirl, I loved it because it is easy to apply, it's like a crayon, paint my eyes very easily without having to spend several times. the only thing I liked is that it ends too fast.

This eyeliner goes on nice and smooth and doesn't pull my delicate eye area like some other brands. I like that you don't have to sharpen it also.

Ah, Cover Girl, my very favorite eye liner! So affordable and works so neatly!

Love this liner and the color I got was perfect. Love that I don't have to sharpen either.

I've used this eyeliner since I very first started wearing it years ago, I really like it! The only thing is once i've used it several times and get to about the middle after I wind it up and go to put it on it breaks, luckily when it breaks it sticks to my eyelid and I can gently pull the broken piece off without smearing it or dropping it on my clothes or floor. I don't know why it breaks off, I do not wind it up to far or anything. It lasts for a long time and you never need to sharpen it :)

This eyeliner makes it super easy to keep a straight line and it stays put all day. No more raccoon eyes around here!

I love this eyeliner. It is perfect for anyone, and the color are best. It is smooth to apply.

Great eyeliner. Did not bother my eye area as some eye makeups have done in the past. Comes off easily at night. Love the soft feel when applying (does not feel like I am poking at my eye) also love the self sharpening feature.

Awesome eyeliner. Soft and smooth, but not too soft. It is even self-sharpening. I love that feature! I would definitely recommend.

I received the charcoal to test out and usually would go for black eyeliner but this was perfect. I love the fact that it does not have to be sharpened, very convenient.

I was skeptical about this eyeliner at first. I loved the fact that I didn't have to sharpen it. Very easy to use, long lasting and water resistant.

I struggle to get my eyeliners on straight because I've had to have multiple procedures on my eyes/eyelids so I have small indentations. Not a problem with this eyeliner! I love it! And the color is classy to.

Love this!!! Love the point on the eye liner...and the color! I would buy this one again.

Sadly, this is just not the eyeliner for me. I have really weepy eyes therefore I need a really long lasting waterproof eyeliner. I gave it to my sister and she loves it! But she doesn't have weepy eyes and doesn't wear contacts.