They are just not for me They donot go smoothly on my eyes and I found it hard to apply . I got a set and I already throw it away ): i have yet to find my best pen eyeliner

I love this eyeliner for tightlining. It goes on really easily so I don't have to keep going back over it to get it black. It doesn't last as long as I would like, but that's not a huge deal. It doesn't run it just fades.

Liked it I did like the fact that this product did as advertised. It did go on smoothly and was creamy. It blended well and was highly pigmented. After a couple of hours it did smudge. It could have been that I did not set it well.

Fun shades some work What I love...Color SELECTION and COLOR DELIVERY. Also this is a soft pencil that glides on and doesn't pull the skin!! What I DO NOT LOVE... Great to smudge slightly but too smudgy... Definitely need to set with eye shadow /powder/ or liquid liner and touch up.

love the way it glides on but its really hard to get off

This eye pencil glides on so smoothly, you barely have to touch it to your eyelid to line your eyes. I absolutely love it! The only drawback is that it is REALLY hard to get off!

Great eyeliner, goes on smooth and lasts all day. Easy to put on and remove.

I love the color variety. I love the 30 seconds or so before it dries and you can blend and smudge away! It does not stay put though. Still get racoon eye's!

I got the black and brown for an everyday look and many commented on how lively I looked

Not my favorite eye liner, but ok for the price. Rubs off fairly quickly. I'd like it more if it were more waterproof-ish.

I love these!! They go on like a cream and really outlast most eyeliners i've used. The colors are so vibrant they really make your eyes pop!! They are a little pricey, but if you hold out until they come on sell, or Sephora offers the little mini sticks as samples then you can stock up really good.

Goes on so smoothly and is offered in great colors but I wish it lasted a little longer.

Actually work 24/7 Love love love these pencils. The color selection is fantastic and they really do stay on all day. I have 5 of the colors and love all of them. I want to get so many more! They are pricey, though, which is a shame, but they do last forever.

These are some of my favorite eyeliners, and I have repurchase a few of the colors in the past.

Absolutely a must have! They are highly pigmented,long lasting,easily removes with makeup remover. Beautiful colors and excellent brand