I love pumpkin pie but I'm not a huge fan of sugar-free anything but went into my review with an open mind and unfortunately just as I thought it definitely tastes like sugar-free products. I do love that Torani uses Splenda as opposed to any of the other alternatives. My favorite out of the two was definitely Hazelnut. I'd say if you're not used to Sugar-Free go with the cane sugar based or keep in mind that it will taste different. I love that Torani has this as an option for those who do not want the extra sugar for one reason or another.

The Pumpkin was the second of two syrups I was able to try and wasn't such a big fan. There were two things this flavor had against it for me-splenda and pumpkin flavor. I'm not a big fan of either. However it did add the extra boost to my pumkin spice coffee that I had in the cabnet. They did make a nice pair.

The Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie Torani syrup was not my favorite. I just can't get over the fake sugar taste. I'm sure the regular version tastes great though!

While I love that this was a sugar free option, I wasn't a big fan of the flavor. It tasted a little bit too artificial for me, but then again, I don't like many things that artificial pumpkin flavor. All the other syrups I've tried have been fabulous though. While I'm not a fan of this in my coffee, I made a mean pumpkin pie milkshake for my husband using some pumpkin puree and the Torani syrup!

As a full-sugar gal, let me preface this review by saying that I do not prefer the sugar-free version of anything. This flavor of Torani DOES have a pumpkin flavor, but not a pumpkin pie flavor. It is not quite "spicy". And I would prefer it were sweeter, but this may be the taste-profile for a person who is used to sugar-free products. You can successful cover the Splenda after-taste if you use this syrup in conjunction with sweetened condensed milk in, for-instance, a DIY Pumpkin Spice Latte. I would recommend using this particular flavor in a Skinny Pumpkin Pie Martini, or as an EggNog flavoring (since the heavy sweetness of the EggNog would mask the Splenda).

As I had mention in my previous review I would give the syrups to my adult daughter to try. Following is her review of the sugar free French Vanilla and the Pumpkin Spice. "They are okay if used in the right mix - too much makes the coffee terrible and it's hard to figure it out. I have used them twice so far - second time was better. Need to be mixed with creamer, which I didn't do the first day. Second day, I had a cappuccino and this worked better. I prefer the Pumpkin to the Vanilla. So I will keep them around, however will likely take me a few years to use them up " One other comment that I have, is that I have been unable find the syrups in the supermarkets near me. Not sure why. I had planned to put some of the coupons on the shelf with the syrups.

I got my box about a week ago and received the Hazelnut and Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie. I tried the sugar free pumpkin pie flavor first because it peaked my interest. The smell is very light but you can certainly tell that there is pumpkin in it. I tried the syrup 3 ways:1) as is 2) in hot coffee 3) in iced coffee. Alone, it really is not all that good. In hot coffee it tastes the best. You can taste the pumpkin pie aspect of it. In iced coffee it was not that great because, the after taste is very artificial. The sugar free really comes through in iced coffee. All in all it is a decent syrup and something that is nice for the holidays.

I received the sugar free pumpkin pie and sugar free vanilla. I am also not a big splena fan. I tastes too sweet and a little fake. I would have liked to have received a regular flavor so I could have compared the two. If I can find it in the store, I will purchase a regular flavor.

I loved the Pumpkin pie flavoring, but have a hard time with the splenda after taste.... I would love to try the full flavored version, I think I would like that much better.

I received a bottle of the Torani Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie Syrup from SheSpeaks. This syrup really does taste like pumpkin pie, but I do not like the taste of Splenda. I think that I would have enjoyed this flavor if it was the regular version of the pumpkin pie syrup.

I was really excited to see that I received the Pumpkin Pie flavor until I noticed it was sugar free. I avoid artificial sweeteners, but tried this one anyway. The pumpkin flavor was really good and tasted just like pie. I am a fan of Starbucks' pumpkin latte, so this is definitely a good way to make it at home. Unfortunately the sugar-free has that obvious "sugar alternative" aftertaste, which ruined it for me. I would buy the pumpkin pie, but I'd make sure it wasn't sugar-free! I know many people need to avoid sugar though and don't mind the flavor, so I would recommend this to them.

This was probably the worst flavor that I could have received. I do not like pumpkin pie or nutmeg (double whammy). I honestly did not try this product and gave it away to someone that enjoys pumpkin pie. I did immediately go to a local store and replace the sugar free pumpkin pie flavor with a caramel syrup that I could get creative with

The only reason I am not giving this product a higher rating is because it was sugar-free. I'm really opposed to using artificial sweeteners and I think they give the product a bitter aftertaste, which I definitely noticed in the Pumpkin Pie flavor. HOWEVER, I am a huge fan of Pumpkin-flavored products and I was actually surprised by how nicely it tasted with a little coffee and milk. It blended together very well and gave my coffee a little spice kick that it needed. That being said, I probably wouldn't buy Pumpkin Pie just because they make a creamer that is Pumpkin Spice which is NOT sugar-free, so I wouldn't feel bad about drinking it. The sugar-free part of this syrup truly was the only downside.

As part of the Torani Syrup campaign I was able to try the sugar free pumpkin pie syrup and was very excited! Although i have to admit I was a little bummed I received the sugar free version as I tend to stay away from the "fake" sugars. While I think the flavor is delicious, I only gave 3 stars because of the classic Splenda after taste. You definitely know you're drinking a sugar free product by the taste. I also received the Hazelnut and I was much happier with the taste of that. Overall, I think it's a great product and will be sure to try their other regular syrups!

Overall I think the flavor is good however I am not a fan of Splenda. I will use what I have but I wouldn't purchase this flavor.