this is a great liquid eyeliner! last all day, easy to use felt tip applicator. im a big fan, especially for the cheap price! i have only used the black, but i am happy with the color and consistency.

This is a great eyeliner! Very comparable to pricier brands. Like with all liquid eyeliner, you need to have a steady hand to apply it to get good results. It doesn't flake or budge at all.

Great eyeliner.I love it.

amazing product I have the color in black, great pigmentation, glides on smoothly, simply inexpensive and amazing

Absolutely LOVE this eyeliner. I have it in Midnight, and you will never see another color like this. It is the deepest blue, but doesnt look like black, surprisingly. It stays on your eyes wonderfully, and it doesnt smear. I cant wait to try the other colors out! Elf did it again!

This product works wonders! The only thing that you have to make sure of is that you practice practice practice! This applies to all liquid eyeliners because if you make one move, it can mess up your whole eye. I use this product every day on my upper lash line, it gives such an intense look and I get many compliments on my eyes during school.

Love it along w their eyeliner pen! i think its the best bang for the buck!

I LOVE this eyeliner!!! I put it on in the morning and it will still look good at the end of the day, would recommend it to anyone!! im pretty picky about my eyeliners too and this is deffinatley one of the best!

i love E.L.F products. great quality and so affordable. i think i own just about everything they offer. i have some ehat sensitive skin and this makeup has never caused me a problem. the eyeliner goes on so fluidly and evenly. i just love it and use it everyday.

I use this eyeliner all the time. It is great for the price, its only a $1. Not bad at all!!!

Elf brand is the BEST! If your looking for an eyeliner that stays put throughout the day, this one is the one to get! I got it for a great price at Target, but you can get the elf products anywhere. Tip: to get your eyeliner to stay put longer, get a fine-liner brush, pick your color of eye-liner, get the same color of eye shadow, and after you apply the eyeliner dip the brush into the eye shadow and put over your liner. That way you have guarenteed no smudge, or smear, eye-liner! :)

love this eyeliner I'm always using especially for being a cheaper price.

On of my favorite liquid liners. I use a variety of different liner types and if i want that precise cat eye I definitely lean towards this one.

I swear by E.L.F products. I love their liquid eyeliner. Now i will say the formula of their products that you buy in the store are a lower quality then the products you buy online, they changed their formula so a lot of the products in store are still old formula. But i love the eyeliners, and their eyeshadow...i love it all :)

I love e.l.f. cosmetics. This liquid eyeliner is a great product. My daughter loves it and buys it often.