When I got these, I thought that my 2 dogs would go crazy for them since they are #1 treats, #2 smells like beacon, #3 pretty presentable. I was wrong. My dogs took one sniff of these treats and ran the other direction. I was so shocked. What is in this thing that would make my dogs who would eat just about anything you put in front of their faces, run away from it? All I can say is that these treats were gone to wastes. Apparently, my dogs knows what is good for them and what is bad! HAHA