It is a great mascara but too expensive

Great but can clump at times. use a light hand

This is an awesome mascara! I am a huge mascara fanatic and love trying new ones when they come out. This is one of the only ones I actually purchase again and again. It volumizes better than others. The only thing is, it clumps easily so keep a metal lash comb handy! It also dries out easily for some reason, but I use it so often that I rotate them out frequently.

Awesome mascara! It lengthens and adds great volume to my lashes. Sometimes I even get people asking where I got my fake lashes from..go try some!

I love the way that this mascara is able to stretch out and separate my lashes without giving them clumps. The ultra black formula also makes them stand out nicely. However, beware of the wet formula. If you don't give this mascara sufficient time to dry, you may find yourself with some lashes stuck together creating that not so appealing spidery lash look. With consistent use, the formula becomes slightly drier (this happens with all mascaras regardless of formula) which makes stuck together lashes less of an issue. The brush on this mascara is a true winner, as the bristles on the very tip of the wand can be used to coat the hard to reach inner corners, and makes painting your lower lashes a snap. Another thing is that this mascara isn't waterproof at all, however that isn't an issue for me. It lasts all day for me with no flakes or running, but those of you who are exposed to more humid or wet environments on a day-to-day basis may want to look for another mascara.

Oh my goodness best mascara I've ever used. It makes lashes appear much longer than any I've ever used. I usually only use one coat. I love the brush because it doesnt get clumpy. It lasts all day.

Curl BEFORE you apply this mascara for best results. Lengthens and volumizes lashes nicely, and doesn't flake at all during the day.

I first tried this mascara when I purchased a beauty kit from Benefit that had a mini They're Real mascara in it. It defines each and every single lash and makes them look so much longer. The wand separates the lashes perfectly so they never clump. I loved it so much that I purchased a full size one.

I love it! Gives the lashes major length, I just wish it made the lashes look a little thicker. Doesn't smell bad like a lot of mascaras do, isn't irritating to the eyes, doesn't clump, and doesn't run!

Easy application, makes eyelashes WAY longer than other products. Didn't have to apply multiple coats! Definitely a great product.

Got this in a birthday present from Sephora for being a VIB and this mascara is amazing!! I just purchased a full size. It makes your lashes look so long and beautiful. I would definitely recommend using an eye brush (a "spooly", a clean mascara wand) to make sure your lashes are separated before you apply. I also don't recommend curling your lashes once you have applied a few coats of this mascara - it's best left alone. Hands down my favorite mascara.

my new favorite mascara! its simply the best, I have tried many but non have left my real lashes looking like falsies. it never clumps and it never smudges! its just amazing.

This is my holy grail mascara. Every time I wear it, I get compliments on my lashes because they are so thick and long. It doesn't flake or smudge around my eyes and lasts all day. I do use a makeup remover to remove it, even though it is not technically waterproof.

I got this sample size from ulta with purchase of one of the full size products , and i felt in love with this mascara, i went and bought a full size!

I love the Benefit brand!! I just bought this mascara the other day. This mascara delivers what the product says it will!!! The mascara lengthens and volumizes my lashes, without clumping and "spider lashes". Worth the splurge!!!!