i have always wanted to try a gel liner....because it looks so clean and polished so i decided to buy this maybelline one and i absolutely love it. its much easier to use the gel rather than liquid. and it just glides on your lid. i dont use this during the day because the black is very dramatic and dark but when i go out during the evening, i use it and its just amazing. it also stays on for a while. i had it on for the whole night (i know its bad) when i slept over someones house and the next morning it still looked fresh and my mom even asked what kind it was because she really liked it( after having it on the whole night). the only thing is that you might need to use an eye makeup remover, because it is sort of hard to take off with just regular makeup remover pads that i use. but ya otherwise....really good product.