Sweet I've purchased this product after going through so many different types of eyeliners, liquid, gel, crayon... I picked this up at Target for only a dollar, which was a great deal. I had also figured that if it turned out to be terrible, then a dollar wouldn't have been a huge waste. The product was very runny, easily smudged since it took so long to try and hard to apply due to the very very thin brush. I ended up switching out the brush with an old bottle of liquid eyeliner and it did apply better. I would only recommend this item for someone who needed to practice putting on liquid eyeliner - which does take some practice.

Sweet I've purchased this product after going through so many different types of eyeliners, liquid, gel, crayon... I picked this up at Target for only a dollar, which was a great deal. I had also figured that if it turned out to be terrible, then a dollar wouldn't have been a huge waste. The product was very runny, easily smudged since it took so long to try and hard to apply due to the very very thin brush. I ended up switching out the brush with an old bottle of liquid eyeliner and it did apply better. I would only recommend this item for someone who needed to practice putting on liquid eyeliner - which does take some practice.

Elf Liquid Eyeliner WILL ALWAYS BE MY GO TO EYELINER!!!

Good but not the best It was eh okay I have honestly had better liquid liner but it was still good!

Not a favorite I didn't love this one. Seemed a little messy for me. I would rather save my money and buy one a little more expensive if it works better.

perfect wing!!! use it in my everyday make up routine. glides on smooth and easy to handle and maneuver for the PERFECT wing liner...LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this product!!!

It was fairly good This is a nice product, however i personally felt that it smelled very chemically. And I thought it it took a few coats to really get a nice solid black line. I would use it again but I don't think I would buy it all the time.

It was fairly good This is a nice product, however i personally felt that it smelled very chemically. And I thought it it took a few coats to really get a nice solid black line. I would use it again but I don't think I would buy it all the time.

I have this on hand. Love how it goes on and easy to apply. Price is good too.

Unsatisfied Love elf products but this one wasnt what i expected ....

Not the best This is a good product since it's so affordable but it isn't as opague as I like my eyeliner to be. It also smudges really easily so that sucks

converted me to an Elf lover Having not been a big fan of Elf products, I was plesantly surprised to find myself actually liking this liquid eyeliner. Although what I do not like about it is how it takes a bit to dry so it does smudge easily until then but overall it has good pigmentation, bold & intense color payoff, great precision of the tip, easy to hold.

Okay products. The products are okay, however, they do not last long.

I liked this eyeliner I just wish there was more and not such a small container.

Eh This product is relatively easy to apply and lasts pretty long but it seems to lack pigment