Ok. I would love this product if only it wasn't so wet. I have to sit with my eyes closed for about 10 minutes in order for it not to smear. I also have a hard time with getting a thin line. If those two things were different I would give it 5 stars. I like it otherwise. I got it in a 5 piece set with two other liquid liners and 2 pencils. Its good for someone whose practicing or wants a thick line.