I really like this eyeliner!! The only thing about it that is keeping me from giving it a fifth star is the fact that the first time I used it the applicator broke. I didn't get too upset, it was only a dollar after all!! It's still very usuable, and I use it every day. It stays on better than a traditional 'crayon' type eyeliner (which I use on the bottom of my eyes). It keeps a dark line with out ever smudging or flaking which is super important to me. I'm pretty picky about which products I use on my eyes and this one passes my 'snob' test, hands down!!