Super black and creamy/1 Last on my eyes all day long without smudging.

Pigmented I used to use this many many years ago and of course I had to have every color...It applied creamy and was really pigmented especially the black,brownn and blue shades! Just some colors were a little waxy and I had to apply a few times to achieve a bold line...

I have never used it, but my granddaughter tells me it is really great.

Good eyeliner that goes on smoothly and stays on for quite a while. I like that it comes with a brush and the price is great!

Creamy formula that lasts. I have really oily eyelids and my liner was smudge-proof for a good 18 hours. The product does dry out quickly, but you can't beat the price.

The product comes in a cute little glass containter, and is basically just a cream eyeliner. It has a pre packaged angled brush which was too large for my eyes and make of super rough material. I traded it out for one of my MAC eyeliner brushes and it was much better. It goes on super smooth with no tugging. The color pay off is great, it really is a true black. I love to do cat eyes with this product. It stayed on all day and was pretty smudge resisitant. But be warned, your going to need makeup remover to get this eyeliner off, water and soap was a no go, it didn't even really budge a whole lot. But once I put some makeup remover on there, it came right off. It's much cheaper than other products, and although it takes a little skill to apply, it looks amazing when done right.

It does dry out in about a month BUT it is creamy and stays on forever. Best drugstore gel liner in my opinion. The brush it comes with is pretty useless, however.

This product is okay, I have owned a lot of cream and gel liners, and this is better then some and worse then some but for the price, its a good product

I really like this product. It can be a bit messy if you dont know how to apply it correctly. I wish the brush was a bit thinner.

I've always kind of used this for my go-to cat eyeliner and its so amazing, creamy, and doesn't dry out....the brush is ok, if you don't have an alternative its not going to be terrible to use, and i even alternate between this brush and others that i own so it is good...wet n wild has hits and misses..this is a hit ^.^...their new matte lipsticks are also really good!...maybe i'll do a review on them lol

I love this for top liner. Whenever I tried it for my water line it made my eyes really irritated and ran. Its probably just my eyes though because I have really bad allergies. it stays all day and even longer when I wear it as top liner though. I have recommended this to so many people in the past and many of them say that they can not find it anymore. I'm not sure if it just sold out in my area or if it is discontinued. I hope its not, I've had mine too long and it's starting to dry out. I need another one.

Try Kmart...it was 50% off...get a deal! I bought it in black and purple and I love them both. The little brush it comes with is not that bad either :-)

I completely agree with pederzani's comments. I'm a big fan of Bobbi Brown but gave this a shot (thank you ladies at makeupalley.com). I use my MAC brush because the one provided is just too harsh but otherwise it's a great product (especially for the money).

This Creme Eyeliner stays on all day and goes on great. It's dark and looks great on eyes. But, sometimes I feel that it doesn't smudge but parts of it end up on my face if I touch my eye. It's okay, but I wouldn't re-purchase it.

Very low price but doesnt last long on your face.