I enjoy the ease of how this eyeliner glides over the eyelid with preciseness. I does not smudge or melt. I do not quite know how to use the sponge on the back to smudge the eyeliner. But as for the eyeliner it is my new go to .

This is the first eyeliner I have ever used in my life, and I LOVE it. I accidentally bought the Charcoal color instead of the black/noir color, so..... I was a bit disappointed. However, I must admit that Charcoal probably looks better because it's not as harsh as straight black would be...? IDK. It's so smooth for a pencil liner, and it looks fabulous. I really don't know how to use the smudging sponge in the back. Every time I try, it either takes all the color off, or doesn't take anything off. I don't know.......... Oh, how I wish I had been a SheSpeaks Tester. :'(

This is my go to eye liner. It is easy to apply and you can take your look from defined to smokey easily with the smudge brush or your finger.

I received this product in my kit. It works great. It stays on and doesn't disappear. Very easy to apply.

Typically I don't use an eyeliner because in the past, they always were kind of dry and dragged my skin as I tried to use them. The CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner was different than those. The tip is very smooth on the skin and goes on easily - more easily than a wet liner and much more smoothly than a dry pencil. I liked the look when I was done and the "smudging" end on the eyeliner gave the lid line color a smooth, soft look. I'm not sure how long it will last, but with the effect and ease of applying it, I'd buy another.

last all day.. great color

love love this eyeliners easy to go on easy to come off when you want it to my number one brand

I tried this on a shespeaks test. This liner is so easy to apply. You can make the lines thin or dark, sharp or smooth and play with it with the smudging tip. I love how you never have to sharpen it. And best of all it lasts all day no smearing or smudging and washes off easily.

Great product. Goes on nice ans smooth.Love it

I'm not one to use pencils anymore for eyeliners. I usually stick to liquid or brush-on gel types. But, when I received this in my "Best of P&G" kit, I was totally suprised once I used it. It went on smooth, and was easy to go from a thin line to a thick and vice versa. This eyeliner didn't bend, break, or get mushy while using it either, which are the main reasons why I stay away from them usually. I typically use a very light eyeshadow or don't line my lower lashes at all since I'm a pale girl. But, I went right on with this and lined the bottom anyway. I used the smudger end of the pencil afterwards, and was very pleased with the outcome. You can truly get a "smokey" blended line with this, and it's quick to do. The color they sent me was espresso....which is a great color, and I'm looking forward to purchasing this again in the future!

I love the CoverGirl perfect Point Plus Eyeliner. It goes on so smooth and easy and is water resistant. You dont have to sharpen it which is wonderful because I know i get tired of keeping track of where my sharpeners are. I will continue to use this and no other eyeliner can replace it.

I received this eyeliner in my P&G kit! It came in Expresso, which is a hue I never get in eyeliner. I FREAKIN' love it! Easy to apply with its convenient twist action! I love it!

It went on very smoothly. It's fantastic. I love the espresso color! very rich in pigments.

my step daughter wears a lot of eyeliner. She said she loves this and it went on well. Lasted through out the day. It's a winner

Love how easy it was to go on and it didn't smudge off I like how it looks on my eyes