This is my favorite cream eyeliner. It's cheap! $3 and it comes with a small slanted eyeliner brush and it works very good also. I use this product everyday. I

I love the black cream eyeliner. It's cheap and it stays on all day!

Good product for the price.

My favorite gel eyeliner. Great staying power, price and colors.

I absolutely loved my E.L.F. cream liner in black. I used it on a daily basis. It glides so smoothly making application time very short! I've had at least three containers of these. Unfortunately I've had so many because they dried out so quickly. I'm not sure if whatever they use in the formulation dries quickly or the jars don't have a great seal, but if they would fix this it would be 5 stars for me.

I love this eyeliner, but I had to give it 4 stars because I have purchased them in 3 colors, and only the black was good. The golden was actually a LIME GREEN color and the white was not pigmented at all. However, I'm completely in love with the black cream eyeliner and I use it whenever I want a dramatic wing or whenever I put eyeliner above my top lashes.

This gel liner is amazing, it is better than the M.A.C black track gel liner, the pigmentation is great and it stays on the whole day, it will not wear off. E.L.F's best product.

they should call this a tatoo i swear!!! it literally stays on all day!!!! and it isnt that hard to apply on especially when u take the time to master it

i always stock up on these it my only liner i use it stays on all day it doesn't smear like othe cream eyeliners...

True to its color. Stays on for a long time.

Just picked this up in the color coffee and it is amazing. My first cream eyeliner and I am addicted.

E.L.F. has hit a home-run on this one! This eyeliner is much better than the liquid - it stays on throughout the day and the colors are fantastic! And the brush allows you to choose the thickness. Don't let the size of the container fool you, either - this will last you a while. Love it!

E.L.F cosmetics really out did themselves on this product. It goes on so smooth and LAST throughout the entire day! It is amazing that for $3 you can have so much product and at such great quality! E.L.F your my hero!