My mother introduced me to this eye makeup remover ages ago and its the only eye makeup remover that i swear by! You put a little on some toilet paper and all of your eyeliner, mascara and anything else around the eyes comes right off! This even easily removes waterproof mascara. It may be a little bit more expensive then what you would want to spend but its worth it and the product does go on sale and when its on sale I'll buy 12 bottles at a time to split with my mother because we both love it so much.