I bought it for my black lab Josie and she loved it. She is picky but she liked the chewnola. It keeps her busy for a little while.

HI It does smell kind weird, but my dogs love these things. It kept my Foxxie busy it chewing it, so I know she loves it. She goes crazy when she sees the bag.

I thought it would be great for the dogs to chew on,has three layers so it would last awhile,neither dog would touch it.I think if it smelled better (more like meat )they might have tried it.