My beagle loves these but they are messy so we've switched him to the ones without the granola stuff on the outside. Think they are called just Busy Rollhide or something like that.

I thought it would be great for the dogs to chew on,has three layers so it would last awhile,neither dog would touch it.I think if it smelled better (more like meat )they might have tried it.

I thought this would be something new and a special treat for our dog. It probably would still be good (if not made in China, I didn't look to see then), but only used outdoors as it was very messy.