i just got this in the duo green (shadow) and moss (liner). it's not a good product. the staying power is less than an hour, even with a primer underneath the shadow. the liner, moss, is more of a dark pewter brown with gold glitter. it's not very good by itself. i guess it could work as a base for a nice green color, but i was kinda disappointed. i paid seventy-six cents for it (yay target clearance!) but probably won't repurchase it for $3 i will be disappointed in!

yes they totally are!

I love elf products. They work well and are inexpensive.