I'm a very picky eyeliner person. This liner went on very well. I was not a big fan of the smudge tool at the end. The color stayed on a good part of the day. A good product, but not my favorite.

This was a good product but the color that I received was brown, and with my brown skin tone it did not show up well. It was a very smooth product. I will have to try black!

I received this in my P&G kit and I really love it. It has its own sharpener so that was a plus. I also like how smooth it goes on. I didn't have the run with this eyeliner that I normally have with others. It came in expresso which is a color I love so that was great. Got many compliments on how nice my eye makeup looked. Thanks P&G

Its ok. It glides smoothly but it doesn't stay put all day like some other brands but for the money its good.

This eyeliner is wonderful! It is long lasting, goes on smoothly, and the color is great. I really like the fact that you don't have to worry about a sharpener as you just twist the pencil tip up as you need it. I also like how it has the smudging tip right at the other end. Out of all of the different eyeliners I have tried, this has been my favorite. Now if only they would offer a white one, it would be absolutely perfect!

Love how easy it was to go on and it didn't smudge off I like how it looks on my eyes

my step daughter wears a lot of eyeliner. She said she loves this and it went on well. Lasted through out the day. It's a winner

It went on very smoothly. It's fantastic. I love the espresso color! very rich in pigments.

Very easy to use this eyeliner. I really like that it comes with a built in smudging tip.

I liked the way this went on, wasnt really my color as i prefer black, but overall great product

worked well

so smooth and easy to use and it does last, I love this stuff and i think I am going to switch to this brand. It looks good and doesn't skip or run off.

I received this eyeliner in my P&G kit! It came in Expresso, which is a hue I never get in eyeliner. I FREAKIN' love it! Easy to apply with its convenient twist action! I love it!

I love the CoverGirl perfect Point Plus Eyeliner. It goes on so smooth and easy and is water resistant. You dont have to sharpen it which is wonderful because I know i get tired of keeping track of where my sharpeners are. I will continue to use this and no other eyeliner can replace it.

I'm not one to use pencils anymore for eyeliners. I usually stick to liquid or brush-on gel types. But, when I received this in my "Best of P&G" kit, I was totally suprised once I used it. It went on smooth, and was easy to go from a thin line to a thick and vice versa. This eyeliner didn't bend, break, or get mushy while using it either, which are the main reasons why I stay away from them usually. I typically use a very light eyeshadow or don't line my lower lashes at all since I'm a pale girl. But, I went right on with this and lined the bottom anyway. I used the smudger end of the pencil afterwards, and was very pleased with the outcome. You can truly get a "smokey" blended line with this, and it's quick to do. The color they sent me was espresso....which is a great color, and I'm looking forward to purchasing this again in the future!