One of my fav mascaras. Separates the eyelashes nicely, even application, not clumpy.

Love it but tends to dry out pretty quickly.

I initially received this as a sample from Sephora and it was one of best I have ever received. Your lashes are not only mile long but they still have a natural affect to them as opposed to clumpy and thick. Definitely need to try!

i was given this as a gift from someone and i have always been the type to think this is a wasted product on my short eyelashes. I tried it and to my suprise it actually gives my short lasehes some shape if you know what i mean. They look fuller and more noticable i love this mascara.

There are many reasons why I love this mascara: It has a big wonderful applicator brush. Doesn't have a strong smell. There is the perfect amount of mascara on the brush with no huge clumps when you pull it out. It doesn't make my eyes itch at all. The consistency of the mascara is nice, not too watery or dry. Leaves lashes looking long, dark, and thick. Pretty much exactly what you want, but I actually use Bad Gal Lash and They're Real by Benefit together for perfect lashes.

Great mascara, gives you the appearance of darker, fuller lashes.

Good Not Bad I do love this mascara, but not always. There are days where it smudges super easily, and days where it holds up as long as I can! I do like the brush shape, which is not the kind I normally like.

Good mascara I've tried lots of mascara. When comes to volume this one is good. It's not the best I've tried. It didn't smudge or make it clumpy. But it's also doesn't give much of length so if you just looking for the volume this would be a great choice to try.

I don't see what the fuss is about..I don't find it to be anything but average...just another mascara

It an alright mascara- I use to use this religiously, but the truth is that it's not really any better than what you could find at a drug store.

Its not as great as the other benefit mascaras, but it does do what its supposed to. I would recommend.

I used to use this mascara all the time! This is a great very black mascara that will definitely last all day without leaving that yucky black residue underneath your eyes!

I got a sample of this and wasn't impressed. It was an ok mascara, but my cover girl clump crusher does a much better job for less than half the price.

To be honest, I don't think this mascara is on par with Benefit's usual quality. This mascara doesn't really add as much volume as I would have liked and the darkest color is still too light for my lashes. Also the brush is quite chunky and large and you have to be really careful with application because it kind of ends up getting in the way and you hit your brow bone with the mascara wand. My advice? Go with Benefit's They're Real, it's a way better product, you won't regret it. But then again to each his own. What may work me may not work for you and vice versa.