I tried this product five years ago, and I was pretty happy about it... Until it dried out on me the next day. It's easy to use, BUT the color isn't as pigmented as I'd want it to be and it dried out. I will not be repurchasing this.

Even tho this was only a buck, I should of used it to buy a candy bar :/ I bought this ELF eyeliner pen at Target and I thought it was a good buy because I had used the NYX super thin eyeliner and it was $10. When I went to use it for the first time it was completely dried up! I had to flip it upside down thinking it might help but when that didn't work I opened it up and add a little water to get it moist enough to work. That was a total waist. Some ELF products work great and are perfect dupes but then some are just not and You're better off paying a little extra for higher quality.

The tip is very horrible. The price is good for it though.

I've only bought one of these so far but I do not like the one that I got. Maybe it was just mine but mine came dried up and barely anything showed up when I tried using it. I will not repurchase it but it is cheap. I'll also recommend it because, again, it could just be my specific item.

It definitely does depend on how good the pen that you buy is. I was not super impressed with my felt tip liner - it was a bit difficult to put on, and yes, my eyeliner dried pretty quickly. However, this is a fabulous buy for ONLY A DOLLAR. Maybe you'll have better luck than I did - I dunno. I wasn't super impressed, but maybe that's just me.

Not enough color or something.

Perhaps I had gotten a bad pen, when I ordered. It was dried out, and did not have a consistent application - it was VERY splotchy, and was not pigmented at all.

i hate the way it applies and the tip losses its point after a few uses.

I used to love this product. When I first started orderingthem, they were perfect. Like a felt tip liner for your eyes, easy to control and the liner lasted all day long. It was perfection and so affordable. Then E.L.F. had to mess with perfection. My last 2 orders, I too got some that were dried out completely but the worst thing is they changed the tip. They made it finer which means it is harder to control and harder to apply. I emailed their customer service and got a generic response back and nothing else. I am so disappointed. I know it only costs $1 but why did they have to mess with perfection?

Ordered two online and one of them didnt even work but the other one worked perfectly.

I think I might've gotten one from a bad batch because at the first application it was great considering the price. Great dark color and applied easily. But then at the next application it was dried beyond revival. However, I will be repurchasing to retry

I have to give this a three star rating because my oily eyelids smudge off this product. I would have to set eyeshadow over this if I want it to be long lasting. It lasts longer on my sister than myself. It is easy to use though.

I do like this eyeliner pen but it is not waterproof. It does work well and it is inexpensive but it dries out too easily even when being stored upside down so the ink goes to the tip. It is an ok pen for the price but I've used better.

The formula is actually pretty good; however, depending on the batch you get, you may be disappointed. For instance, the first time I purchased this, it was all dried up. But, I decided to try it again and the formula was great. Definitely stays all day. Unfortunately, the tip isn't as precise as others (such as the Jordana one which is really good as well just not waterproof). I'd definitely recommend others to try this but it may take you a few times before you find a good one. The bright side, it's only a dollar.

First one to work & last This was an amazing surprise, after basically 99% of all the felt-tip liner drying up in a week, no matter the price, this one outlasted them and it was $2 USD. Not only did it not dry out, but it applied very opaque and pigmented (talking about the black liner). It did lasted on my lids all of the day; I thought it would smudge because I had been having very watery eye, but it made it through. I won't say it is the best of them all, but it is in top 10. But bit of warning, make sure to put the lid tightly because if not, the liner will dry out quickly.