SHESPEAKS Your Power to Influence

A Woman's Right to Push

SS Member Image By drodriguez 09.14.08
A Woman's Right to Push
Share Tweet

There is much controversy surrounding the safety of VBAC (vaginal birth after caesarean), so much so that some hospitals are now refusing to admit women requesting this type of birth. A lot of hospitals and birthing centers started dropping their VBAC practices soon after the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) released a 1999 bulletin urging doctors to only perform a VBAC in a setting where proper emergency care is available.

According to an article published in the American Academy of Family Physicians ( the ACOG still promotes the inclusion of VBAC as a birthing option, but it also takes the stance that no current or past study has proven that maternal and neonatal outcomes are better with VBAC than with repeat cesarean.

The American Academy of Family Physicians also provides a list that the ACOG gives to identify candidates for a VBAC:

- One or two previous low-transverse cesarean deliveries.
- Clinically adequate pelvis.
- No other uterine scars or previous rupture.
- Physician immediately available throughout active labor capable of  monitoring labor and performing an emergency cesarean delivery.
- Availability of anesthesia and personnel for emergency cesarean delivery.

One popular 2001 study published in the New England Journal of Medicine ( concluded that women who chose to have a VBAC were at a higher risk of uterine rupture than those women who had planned cesarean deliveries. The study goes on to say that women who were induced using a prostaglandin (a cervical ripening agent) before their VBAC were at a much greater risk of rupture.

These findings, however, are very controversial because they only focus on uterine rupture. For example, the risks of having a second cesarean alone can range from severe infection to subsequent infertility. The findings give no information about other risks of cesareans versus VBAC.

The wide range of conflicting research, studies, and recommendations only add to the confusion of making such an important decision.

After doing the research then sitting down with physician and family, how does a woman decide?

Do you think doctors and hospitals should be required to perform VBAC if a woman has chosen it as her birthing option and is a viable candidate for the procedure?

(If you are thinking about having a VBAC, you can find an extensive list of support groups at

Make a Comment

Comment  *
  • tissakay By tissakay

    As woman who has had four successful VBAC's after a ceseaean, I would have to encourage other women in this situation to try to find a dr who would at least be willing to allow them to attempt a VBAC.

    I was very aware with each of my VBAC's that at any point if my Dr. felt a c-section was necessary that I would be taken to surgery.

    Commnuncation between mother and Dr. is key!

More stories like this