Has The Time Come To Discontinue The Miss America Pageant?

   By SheSpeaksTeam  Sep 09, 2014
193

"There She Is" ... but what for?

Is The Miss America Pageant just another reality TV competition as profound as an episode of The Bachelorette? Is it a charming but harmless nod to a piece of Americana, or a harmful and patronizing objectification of women?

Is it hard to understand, at a time when women outnumber men in universities, and the average woman is a size 14 – why bikini-clad stick figures are strutting around on stages to get scholarship money? Or is there a real-world link to success that contestants gain by competing in this arena?

Hardly anyone would categorize today’s Miss America contestants as unintelligent, inarticulate, apolitical, or detached. Most have attended prestigious universities, earned professional degrees, have exceptional communication skills, maintain a healthy lifestyle and are involved in their communities. What’s not to like about that? And aren’t impressionable teens who have seen the latest Music Awards Shows or celebrity selfies - likely to be unfazed by the pageant’s swimsuit competition?  

As a cultural institution, the Miss America Pageant has come a long way since its 1920’s beginnings as a tourist attraction in Atlantic City. Its historical influence in defining our perception of beauty has been prodded along by 3 memorable Miss New Yorks – namely, Bess Myerson, the first Jewish Miss America in 1945, Vanessa Williams, the first African-American Miss America in 1984, and 30 years later to the day, Nina Davuluri, the first Miss America of Indian heritage. The manner in which each of these women rose above the backlash that followed their historic wins, is perhaps the most effective silencer of pageant critics to date.

But is that really enough to justify continuance?

Should new categories of scored competition such as Problem-Solving, Creativity, Diplomacy, Athleticism or Technology – be added to things like Swimsuit, Talent and Social Platform in order to crown a more relevant ideal? Why do we need a Miss America?

We'd love to hear your opinion - Should the Miss America Pageant be continued or discontinued?

Tell us your thoughts in the comments section below and you’ll be entered to win a $75 Visa Gift Card.*

*This giveaway is open through Sept. 23rd to USA residents over 18 years of age. One entry per person. No purchase necessary.

Congratulations to Winner: Khalessifan

 

Make a Comment

 
SHARE
Comments
gakusan by gakusan | Newburgh, NY
Sep 10, 2014

There should be a contest for women and men who's been contributing to our society, instead of judging them by how they look. After a while, this kind of contests gets old, right?

peaches0582 by peaches0582 | N DINWIDDIE, VA
Sep 10, 2014

I do not see any harm my children enjoy watching it been around for a long time it doesn't bother me.

nothingnew by nothingnew | ATASCADERO, CA
Sep 10, 2014

It's not the same as it used to be when I was a kid and watched every single minute with my cousin picking our top ten. Sad when you think about that being our "sport". I think it's time to end it but there's too much money to be made so I think it will keep dragging on and on.

slim1970 by slim1970 | Sanford, ME
Sep 10, 2014

I can't believe people even watch this... who really cares, I don't.

LostLenore by LostLenore | BELLEVILLE, IL
Sep 10, 2014

I grew up watching Miss America because my mom, a product of the 1950s, somehow enjoyed it. Aside from giggling at idiotic interviews and talent travesties, the only part I looked forward to was the evening gowns. Hey, who doesn't like pretty dresses? As a child I never contemplated the sexism of the swimsuit competition, but like most American teen girls, I developed an unhealthy obsession with trying to be thin. Despite earning academic scholarships for college, I never felt more accomplished than when my father said I looked like Miss America in a one-piece bathing suit. I'm not saying the annual meat parade was solely to blame for my low self-esteem and slightly skewed priorities, but it certainly didn't help. Somehow I got the message loud and clear that how I looked trumped what I thought or how I behaved. It's a message that today's and tomorrow's girls don't need to have reinforced, and pageants like this are long overdue to die out.

1lovefaithhope by 1lovefaithhope | Diamond Bar, CA
Sep 10, 2014

It seems like a valid tradition but new categories can be added and old ones updated to keep it fresh. :)

mervissa by mervissa | WINTER GARDEN, FL
Sep 10, 2014

Another way of objectifying women...and now its been passed on to little girls. Go away pageants!

jimmiss71 by jimmiss71 | MT HOLLY SPGS, PA
Sep 10, 2014

i enjoyed watching this as a teen and young adult and still do watch it today. It provides great opportunities but it probably should be updated to reflect more current beliefs. we don't need swimsuit competitions and life should not be about who is the prettiest or best looking. the talents portion is a good thing and I am sure new ideas could come about to do away with the superficial contest parts of it.

darholley by darholley | ORLAND, CA
Sep 10, 2014

I don't think that it needs to end. Like any other show if people don't like it they can change the channel.

MasterofMom by MasterofMom | FT LAUDERDALE, FL
Sep 09, 2014

With no royalty in the US, this is a rare opportunity for many girls to be a princess for a day & feel adored by admirers. To say that this should be gotten rid of is like saying that we should remove the chance for a girl to feel the success of winning a court case. Not all women feel, think, or act the same. What may be boring nonsense to one woman is the dream of a lifetime to another. When you dismiss "girly" things & call it "feminism" all you're really doing is shutting another woman's dream down because you think YOUR dream is better. We should be willing to accept that not all girls are the same. Supporting females shouldn't be about making sure that one vision of womanhood is ascertained, but about making certain that all women are free to pursue the careers and goals of their OWN choice and making.

Grammio by Grammio | SANDERS, KY
Sep 09, 2014

I haven't watch a beauty pageant in decades, so I certainly wouldn't miss them being televised. I've never liked the swim suit competition, so that should be discontinued even if the pageant goes on.

catnip1222 by catnip1222 | ROCKY FACE, GA
Sep 09, 2014

There are worse things on television than this pageant. I'd rather see adults in pageants than children any day....I personally don't watch it but someone apparently does or it would not still be on!

Zoomie by Zoomie | New York, NY
Sep 09, 2014

I think the Miss America pageant is not owned or produced by Donald Trump and that the Miss South Carolina who gave a confusing reply was a contestant in the Miss Teen USA pageant, not the Miss America pageant. The times I have watched the Miss America pageant, the q and a section was pretty good, and last year the eventual winner was direct and seemed sincere to me.

herbalkate by herbalkate | LOUISVILLE, KY
Sep 09, 2014

I used to love it as a child: the glamour, hair, makeup, evening gowns and talent, but as an adult, I see it more along the lines of a parade of cattle being judged at a state fair. I know the contestants say there is much more to it than that - the scholarships, etc, but the judgment based on physical beauty is all the American public really sees. There should be more focus on a person's heart, soul and mind than her body. The truth of it is that there are always going to be women who love beauty pageants and for those types, they can do as they please and more power to them for trying to achieve their goals. But it isn't something I would want to participate in or allow a daughter of mine to participate in. The only reason people really want to see it these days is to hear the women make jackasses of themselves as Miss South Carolina did a few years ago when answering questions about Americans needing more education on geography. She was hilarious.

csilva by csilva | Grand Island, NE
Sep 09, 2014

I can't say I really care. I don't see a point in it but that is half if what is on tv