SHESPEAKS Your Power to Influence

Was Their Mother A Monster?

Was Their Mother A Monster?

We all remember hearing stories of the highly publicized 2002 kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart and her subsequent rescue 9 months later from her abductor, Brian David Mitchell.  Media reports about the abductor at the time centered around Mitchell and his idea that he is a self-proclaimed profit and was motivated by a "revelation from god" to kidnap Elizabeth Smart. 

Until now, not much has come out about Wanda Barzee, Mitchell’s wife of 17 years and accomplice to the kidnapping.  She was often portrayed as a victim of her husband’s brainwashing in the press.  Barzee has since pled guilty to taking part in the kidnapping and is currently living in a state hospital.  Barzee has not yet received sentencing for her crime. 

For the first time since the kidnapping, Barzee’s children are speaking up about the abuse they suffered at their mother’s hands.  Four of Barzee’s six children (Rhonda, Andrea, Derrick and Lorrie)  recently appeared on the Oprah Winfrey Show to discuss their experiences living with their mother.  Andrea talked of her mother’s treatment in the media when she said, "I think the media portrayed my mother as being a victim of Brian David Mitchell, and I think one of the reasons I wanted to come on this show is to kind of expose her for the monster she is."

According to Barzee’s children, the abuse they suffered from her was more emotional and psychological though sometimes became physical with both Mitchell and Brazee beating the children together.  Lorrie recalls an incident where her mother cooked her pet rabbit and tricked her into eating it saying it was chicken, all the while with a smile on her face.   Andrea remembers getting the idea drilled into her head by her mother that if she were not a part of the family then the family would be fine.

The children managed to move out of the home before the Elizabeth Smart abduction, but they were not surprised to hear their mother and Mitchell were suspects in the kidnapping.  Though they believe she is responsible for her actions, they all have varying ideas of how or whether she should be punished for the crime.  The oldest child, Rhonda, remembers her mother in the earlier "better" years when she appeared to be more loving toward them.  She is the only one in communication with Barzee and did not believe she committed the crime until she pled guilty.

Andrea on the other hand believes her mother should be locked up for good.  She told Winfrey, "I don’t think she should see the light of day again.  As a citizen and as a mother myself, I feel like I have a responsibility to protect children, and I don’t want to see anyone else fall victim to her."

What kind of sentence do you think is appropriate for, Wanda Barzee, the accomplice in the Elizabeth Smart abduction?

Do you think Wanda Barzee should be considered just as guilty as Brian David Mitchell?

Make a Comment

Comment  *
 
 
  • mardel By mardel
    02.26.10  

    Wanda Barzee is 100% responsible for what happened to that innocent child as well!! She witnessed it and did nothing. I don't believe in a person being so manipulated and scared that you could sit there and see the horror a child is going through and don't contact the police! I say give her a life sentence in a dark room and throw away the key!

  • msfriendly By msfriendly
    02.26.10  

    I agree that Wanda Barzee is responsible. Even if she felt manipulated by her husband, she is an adult and needed to go to authorities if she was in no way approving in his actions. She is as guilty as he is.

  • bozemanbrooks By bozemanbrooks
    02.26.10  

    I also agree, lock her up and throw away the key! She is just as guilty as Brian David Mitchell. Even for her own children to say she should be locked up for good tells you something.

  • chriscree By chriscree
    02.26.10  

    Wow...She sure needs help! Hope they pu ther somewhere so she can get it. She was abusive and manipulative. Was she abused herself, I wonder?

  • idahospud By idahospud
    02.26.10  

    She should be sentenced for life,her children have to live with this forever.hopefully the children will not suffer from any kind of mental problems.Too bad the children cannot choose punishment.

  • MadHatter By MadHatter
    03.01.10  

    she is a miserable old woman, and its sad to see that she has done this to her own kids. she doesn't deserve a light sentencing at all! if anything she deserves as much prison time as her husband for what they had done. this is horrible and im happy that her kids are stepping out and pointing out who the real victim is. Elizabeth.... I can't even imagine what she went through in her ordeal at such a young age from these troubled adults. I think Wanda's own parents definably treated her the same way, that is why Wanda thinks in her mind, its alright to treat her kids the same.

  • bbred57 By bbred57
    03.06.10  

    Yes she should, she was just as guilty in this crime against Elizabeth. She did not free her and she allowed him to do whatever he wanted. They both are guilty and should go to prison for the rest of their lives with no possibility of parole. And heaven help her children and what they must live through for the rest of their lives, may they have peace that she will no longer torture them.

  • kyhomebody By kyhomebody
    03.07.10  

    I can't help but be concerned about child abuse in ky it seems like almost everyday there has been another infant killed or badly hurt by its parents.what is wrong with people?

More stories like this