From Scratch Sugar Free/Regular Pumpkin Pie


submitted by darwido {1 Recipe}


 0  Comments Add your Comment

  • Prep Time:
    15 Mins
  • Cook Time:
    1 Hr
  • Total Prep + Cook Time:
    1 Hr 15 Mins
  • Level:
From Scratch Sugar Free/Regular Pumpkin Pie

Makes: 1 pie

Description: I made my very first pumpkin pie from scratch today (I did cheat on the crust; it was a frozen Marie Calendar's pie crust.)! It was a sugar free pie for my parents. Turned out AWESOME!!! Now I can add it to my Thanksgiving meal plan!

2  Small pumkins
3  Large eggs
1  Can of evaporated milk
2 tbsp.  Pumpkin pie spice
1/2 cup  Splenda
1/4 cup  Splenda Brown Sugar Mix
1  Ready-made or homemade pie crust
1/2 cup  Sugar (if you don't want the sugar free version)
1/2 cup  Brown sugar (if you don't want the sugar free version)

Instructions: Bake 2 small pumpkins for 40 minutes at 375 degrees.
Let them cool, and scoop the insides.
Keep the seeds for baking later (300 degrees for 30 minutes -- coat with melted butter and sea salt).
Scrape the pumpkin guts for the puree.
We used a pumpkin scraper from one of the Halloween kits we got from the dollar store.
Add 2 tbsp. pumpkin spice, 3 large eggs, 1 can of evaporated milk, 1/2 cup Splenda for baking and 1/4 Splenda Brown Sugar Mix to the pumpkin guts and puree in a blender.
If you don't want to do the sugar free version, use 1/2 cup sugar and 1/2 cup brown sugar.
Put puree mix in a pie crust. Make sure you brush the sides of the pie crust with butter to keep it from burning.
Bake for 15 minutes at 400 degrees. Turn oven down to 350 degrees and bake for 40 minutes. Check after 40 minutes by placing knife in the center of the of the pie. If it comes out clean, it's done. If not cook 5 more minutes. Repeat until done.
Let cool 2 hours.

Add Your Comment

Choose a rating by clicking on a star:  * 

Enter your comments here.  *


Other recipes in desserts 

White chocolate chip/cranberry cookies.

White chocolate chip/cranb…

By ariels09
May 14, 2012

These are absolutely delicious, sure to please Mom cookies. My Mom loves when I bake her cookies. I grew up with my Mom baking for me and i love it now t…

Cake Mix Sandwich Cookies

Cake Mix Sandwich Cookies

By mmommymusings
May 01, 2013

A super easy cookie recipe that takes a few ingredients and a small amount of time. They are so easy that a child with adult supervision can make them. T…

Colorful Biscuits

Colorful Biscuits

By SuzSpks52
Dec 12, 2017

This will teach you how to take a simple biscuit recipe, and turn it into a spectacular and colorful display for parties or no special reason at all.