Breast Milk Baby: Natural or Not Just Yet?

   By drodriguez  Apr 05, 2011

Our kids diaper them, cuddle them, walk them around in mini-strollers; but how much more should a baby doll teach our children about parenthood?  This is the question a lot of parents are asking since the Breast Milk Baby doll from Berjuan Toys hit the market in Spain.  Children are able to pretend they are breast-feeding the doll by holding the doll to their chest while wearing a vest equipped with sensors that trigger the toy to make suckling noises and motions.  

Some parents have expressed outrage that this toy is on the market and will be available in U.S. stores in just a few weeks for the retail price of $99.  They feel a toy that teaches a child how to breast feed is inappropriate and forces kids to grow up too fast.  Mother of two, Becky Orsinger, was recently quoted in a CBS news report stating why she believes this is not a toy she feels would be appropriate for her daughter to play with.  Orsinger says, "I don’t think it’s a skill I need to teach her specifically at this point wih a doll.  While she’s four years old?  While she’s four years old."

Both the toy company and other proponents of the Breast Milk Baby doll think the doll is a great educational tool that allows kids to mimic a very natural mother-baby experience.  Mother and member of the well-known breast feeding advocacy group La Leche, Laura Korot, tells CBS that she could have used this doll when she had her second daughter and felt that her first child was feeling left out.  Korot explains, "If she could have had a doll similar to that, it could have helped her feel a little more involved in the feeding process."

So what do you think of the Breast Milk Baby doll?

Would you consider buying something like this for your child?

Make a Comment

folowurhart by folowurhart | Maple Shade, NJ
May 24, 2011

I am one of nine children. My mother breast fed us all and she wasn't embarrassed to do it in front of us. When I was little I remember I would breast feed my dolls because I loved them like they were real. I now have a beautiful daughter who is breastfed. I don't think that it is a bad idea. It's not a dirty thing that some try to make it out to be. A lot of people get so tight in the ass about the natural way that we are supposed to be nourished and it's a real shame. It's a true reflection of how backward society has become. BUT...... Why does this doll cost so much? Honestly I can just put some flower stickers on a training bra and gt a burping doll for about $20.

mlhart2 by mlhart2 | Apex, NC
Apr 19, 2011

This is inappropiate for young children. While breast feeding is important it is something you learn about when you are planning to have children. Young girls and boys should be focusing on age appropriate play, not on adult activities - what's next dolls to let them pretend they are conceiving a baby????

DealsFromMSDo by DealsFromMSDo | WAYNESVILLE, MO
Apr 14, 2011

I've seen so many little girls "breastfeed" their baby dolls that I was surprised they actually created a special doll for it. I did see a news special on TV (Good Morning America I think) and this doll came from European country where it's been a hit for several years. This isn't surprising considering breastfeeding isn't considered taboo as it too often seems to be here in the US. It's sad that so many women here still seem so uncomfortable with the whole topic of breastfeeding - whether it's a real baby or a baby doll.

jennifergriola by jennifergriola | west orange, NJ
Apr 13, 2011

I love it. It always sort of bothered me that dolls came with bottles. Especially when so many women choose not to even have bottles in their home. What really did it for me was when my daughter asked me if she could give her newborn cousin a bottle, I was appalled that she had been socialized through dolls to believe that a newborn would be bottle fed (when in reality over 70% of newborn are breastfed). I want my daughters to expect to breastfeed, for them to see it as the norm & dolls that come with bottles, imho, discourage that norm and attempt to make bottle feeding the norm. That said, to each her own. I have had plenty of friends and family members who chose to formula-feed & I myself formula-fed my oldest when she was 6 months old. I can completely understand. I just see it the same issue as play food: I throw away the donuts and soda and that come with the play food--I don't want to normalize that as appropriate eating for my children.

adj333 by adj333 | oklahoma city, OK
Apr 12, 2011

I dont have children but I will tell you if I did that thing would not be in my house! I am all for breastfeeding but that is taking it way to far.

momofsbj by momofsbj | FARMINGVILLE, NY
Apr 10, 2011

I think it is to each his own. If you want it buy it. If you don't leave it. I bet once it becomes the "in toy to have " you will be buying it to!

stellastar23 by stellastar23 | Alpharetta, GA
Apr 09, 2011

I really don't see the big problem with the doll. If you feel it's not appropriate you can always not but the doll.

anbiza by anbiza | Sarasota, FL
Apr 09, 2011

I am trying to understand why people say this doll interferes with kids being kids and forces them to grow up too quickly. Would the people who say this also agree that giving a little girl a bottle to feed to her baby doll does the same thing? I wouldn't spend $99 on this doll because I agree with others who say it isn't necessary, but I completely do not get why anyone would be offended or have a problem with the doll.

xtremejunk by xtremejunk | monticello, NY
Apr 09, 2011

Breast feeding is completely natural.I breast fed all 3 of my children but this doll is disgusting.I have a 6 year old little girl and I would never buy this for her. Breast feeding is for real mommys not pretend play.And for all those who say just don't buy it...well I wont but she will still see the commercials no matter how I try to monitior the television and she will still hear about it from friends and see it in stores.This forces parents to have to answer questions that their little ones do not need to know yet and certainly not at 6 years old!

ljgl16 by ljgl16 | North Brunswick, NJ
Apr 07, 2011

children mimic what they see, if their mom is nursing, they pretend to do so as well, without a special doll. Nursing is as natural as can be, no chemicals or additives just breast milk. It's kind of scary that people find nursing to be so strange. Buying the doll is a choice, hardly the reason your teenager will become pregnant. Why aren't you more excited about the things that actually negatively impact our children?

kimjharvey by kimjharvey | Quartz Hill, CA
Apr 07, 2011

If a child sees their mother breastfeeding a sibling is it wrong too? I don't see a problem with a daughter pretending to be a mother and including breastfeeding in that. It seems that more people are comfortable with sexualizing breasts and letting their children see women in revealing clothing and low cut blouses, than they are with letting them know about breastfeeding. Weird.

ashelyluvu by ashelyluvu | REDFORD, MI
Apr 07, 2011

so if you like the doll dont get mad when your 16 yr old girl is 16 with Bby

msfriendly by msfriendly | MONROE, WI
Apr 06, 2011

I saw this on Good Morning America. I really don't know why people would be so upset over something like this. There are many more things going on in this world to our kids that we should be upset about...this is not one of them.

natikaal by natikaal | CALUMET, MI
Apr 06, 2011

PLEEEASE! Why do people get so up in arms about such silly subjects? It's not like they're making dolls that have sex. Honestly. If you don't want your kid to learn to breastfeed their babydolls, don't doll out the mucho bucks for the thing. (and keep your eyes peeled, likely if they've seen you do it, they're doing it too.) Now, if the doll had to actually latch on, that would be a whole different story. As far as that goes, most kids who see thier moms breastfeed copy the act. It's not like they need the sound effects to go around mimicking mommy. I have known many children, boys and girls alike who have pretended to breastfeed. Kids always like things to be as realistic as possible, and breast-feeding is a natural part of life. When they invent a hooker, I will have issues. Until then, if you don't like the breastfeeding thing, pass by the doll. They don't have to know there is anything special about it.

jmbflower by jmbflower | Enid, OK
Apr 05, 2011

I think it is encouraging girls to grow up way too fast. Breast feeding is a decision that is made while you are pregnant or even after you have baby and try it out. I am a breast feeding mom. It has come very naturally to me and I didn't need a doll to teach how to do it.