Shespeaks Logo
The Ploy of Soy
Special Edition  »  Health and Nutrition  »  The Ploy of Soy
The Ploy of Soy
Esther Blum, MS,RD,CDN,CNS
Posted October 21, 2009

SpEd_soyThe ploy of soy is a big one. There are so many claims that it has health benefits and is the perfect substitute for animal protein. I used to eat a lot of soy myself, but over the years I have unearthed some hard truths that now make me think twice about consuming soy. 

It’s true, many studies have shown traditionally fermented soy--which is the form that is very popular in many Asian cultures--aids in preventing and reducing a variety of diseases including certain forms of heart disease and cancers.  But just to be safe, I recommend using these products as a condiment, and not the mainstay of your meals.

I used to eat a lot of soy myself, but over the years I have unearthed some hard truths that now make me think twice

I’ve come to believe through my years of research and practice, that soy is not the wonder food product makers claim it to be. Let’s delve deeper into some of the bigger problems with soy:

 

 

·     Soy lacks methionine—an essential amino acid required to build muscle. I guess that’s why you don’t see a lot of vegetarian body builders.

·     Soy suppresses thyroid function because it contains phytoestrogens that can disrupt hormonal balance.

·     Soybeans are high in phytic acid, which, in large amounts, can block the uptake of essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, copper, iron and zinc in the intestinal tract.

·     Soybeans are very new to the food chain of modern man, since it was never used for food in paleolithic times.  Many people are not only allergic to soy, but suffer with extreme gas and bloating from it.  If you have any type of autoimmune condition, especially colitis or celiac disease, you should remove soy from your diet immediately.

·     Soy is very high in arginine, and can exacerbate cold sores and herpes outbreaks.

If you’re trying to get soy out of your diet, you should know that soy is often a wolf in sheep’s clothing, and can have many aliases: Food processors are less likely to list the three letter word "soy" than a technical term such as "textured vegetable protein" (TVP), "textured plant protein", "hydrolyzed vegetable protein" (HVP), "vegetable oil" or "MSG" (monosodium glutamate). Ingredient lists also include words such as "vegetable oil", "vegetable broth", "boullion", "natural flavor" or "mono-diglyceride" that do not necessarily come from soy, but are likely to. Soy is found in everything from Pizza Hut to Baskin Robbins to vitamins and, yes—even asthma inhalers..

If you do consume soy, I suggest you use it judiciously and only in its fermented form: miso, natto, tempeh, soy sauces, and fermented tofu.  The fermentation process stops the effect of phytic acid and increases the availability of isoflavones. The fermentation also creates the probiotics--the "good" bacteria that increase the quantity, availability, digestibility and assimilation of nutrients in the body.

What’s your take on soy?  

 

 

 

 

 

 

LivingGorgeous.com
 
Esther Blum, MS,RD,CDN,CNS
Esther Blum is a Registered Dietitian and Holistic Nutritionist practicing in New York City. Esther is the author of the bestselling book Eat, Drink and Be Gorgeous: A Nutritionist's Guide to Living Well While Living It Up, Secrets of Gorgeous , and 2010 Daily Calendar: A Year of Living Gorgeously. She is sought after by national food and beverage brands as a spokesperson, and maintains a busy private practice in New York City. A self-titled Food Fashionista, Esther is an in-demand authority who has appeared on the Today Show and other major network news shows, and is frequently quoted in the press.
42 Comments
momagarry says: on Oct 22, 2009
I am trying to get my family to eat more soy products. They are so healthy for us:)
msfriendly says: on Oct 23, 2009
I think that if you eat a balanced diet and don't overdo any one food, that soy is OK.
mazziemae says: on Oct 23, 2009
I was told I shouldn't eat it because of my thyriod
mazziemae says: on Oct 23, 2009
meant thyroid
pjgriff says: on Oct 23, 2009
I drank the soy shakes for a couple years, and found out my thyroid was low. Now I have to take thyroid medication, Sometimes I wonder if I didn't screw up my thyroid drinking the shakes.
mrazzi45 says: on Oct 26, 2009
My 18 yo son is anaphylactic to milk products ....if it wern't for soy ...????? who knows ! mrazzi45@aol.ccom
mrazzi45 says: on Oct 26, 2009
I have hypothyroidism ...badly ! I knew nothing about soy = low thyroid ?:(
scibirg says: on Oct 26, 2009
If you are allergic to milk, try rice milk. Tastes yummy! Also, I heard that soy may have female hormones in it.
jlincon71 says: on Oct 26, 2009
Wow I didn't know this about soy maybe i should lower my soy intake.
Texmel says: on Oct 27, 2009
What's your take on edamame? You know, the soy beans you can get that are boiled in the skin and you pop them out of the skin and eat them? My family loves them, altho we only get them when we go to Asian restaurants (my picky boys don't like the way I make them).....
leopat1010 says: on Oct 28, 2009
Everything in moderation is the key.
nyy4000 says: on Oct 28, 2009
Very interesting article. I have found in the last few years or so that I have been having allergic reactions to something used in different food products. Haven't been able to pinpoint what it could be. Now I'm wondering about soy....
kathi22 says: on Oct 29, 2009
Soy Is NOT good for you!!! Especially young girls and woman who are trying to have babies. My daughter has precousious puberty. The first question the doctor asked when we went in was is she drinking soy milk? she was on a daily basis. Trust me on this moms...soy effects the hormones of your kids. I have researched this and although there are conflicting beliefs why take the chance. we will never know if the soy milk was the sole problem but my daughter will have to have hormone shots for the next 7 years and i strongly reccoommend parents doing research on this..
njmomto3 says: on Oct 29, 2009
I agree with you kathi22. Hope your daughter is okay.
kittycat2 says: on Oct 29, 2009
I enjoy soy and soy products but don't go out of my way to find it in products.
lisaberger says: on Oct 29, 2009
As a recent cancer survivor (endometrial - an estrogen mediated cancer), I was advised to avoid soy if possible. Okay to have some, like soy sauce, but don't eat a lot. I believe this is because of it's association with estrogen. Anyone else heard this?
littleneko says: on Oct 30, 2009
That is scary kathi22! I'm sorry to hear about your daughter. Lisaberger, my mother is a cancer survivor and she read that women who have had estrogen mediated cancer should avoid soy as well. Her opinion was that soy is safe for those who haven't had that type of cancer. I didn't know that soy could have effects on healthy people. Moderation is good advise, but this is a topic that I should definitely read up on.
andysbabycakes says: on Oct 30, 2009
I read so much in magazines and online about how good soy is for you...then I SOMETIMES read the negative issues about soy. It is not published/talked about near as much. I eat soy very rarely...now I don't feel so bad about not eating what I thought I should have been eating a lot of!! I have thyroid issues and two teen girls..so we are definetly not going to be eating it alot!
caryn8 says: on Oct 30, 2009
No food is perfect. Don't be so critical, soy has a lot to offer. Who promised you it would take the place of every other food we should be eating? I can not stand it when people do not understand that nothing is healthy enough to replace everything else. The rest of us understand that it is a great food to add to our already healthy diet. In my house, we eat tofu once a week. We are not vegans and love a good steak and we still eat our fruits and vegetables too. Do not make it out to be evil.
redrach says: on Oct 30, 2009
Broccoli and tofu stir fry is pretty delicious... over brown rice. Yum.
gardengirl10 says: on Oct 31, 2009
I eat more soy products now because I am just starting menopause, I don't go overboard. I like tofu stir fried with some bok choy, I make tofu "crab cake" a great recipe I got from the giant book of tofu. ---- http://www.recipelink.com/cookbooks/2006/080692957X_1.html ------ I also pack some soy beans in a container for a snack or toss them in my salad. I started eating tofu when my son became a vegetarian a few year back, even though he has started eating chicken I still continue to buy it.
mommyof3ree says: on Oct 31, 2009
WOW! I have thyroid problems and I drink soy milk instead of regualar milk and so does my mom. I'm throwing it all away!!!
ballerine_avec_ardeur says: on Oct 31, 2009
Soy should only be used in the purest form. That is where the media decieves you. Look for Organic, not genaric or natural. Also, if you have thyroid issues... DO NOT use soy. It can create a problem.
estherblum says: on Oct 31, 2009
Live Gorgeously! Esther
estherblum says: on Oct 31, 2009
Sorry-- my comment didn't post properly. For every published study ever done on soy, read The Whole Soy Story (www.thewholesoystory.com). Extremely informational. Soy is estrogenic and can cause early onset of puberty for girls and delayed sexual development in boys. In both sexes, soy can cause fertility issues later on in life. Be extremely judicious when consuming soy: consume it only in fermented forms, and in very small amounts.
sakana says: on Oct 31, 2009
I agree with posts saying that moderation is key. The problem is that it's hard to be moderate when it's hidden in so many foods (if you use vegetable oil or see it in an ingredient list, odds are it's soybean oil) - just like corn and HFCS. Cheap, overproduced, and added to everything.
joy9281 says: on Nov 01, 2009
I do not care for the taste so moderation is no problem for me. If there was a pill with the same benefits I would much rather take this than eat anything with soy. Besides w/ all the4 uncertainty on soy I am not sure we should use much!
mantra says: on Nov 02, 2009
extremely very interesting article..its like an eyeopener for those who rely on soy products..for the so much told high nutrition..thanks for sharing the knowledge with us
mystigal says: on Nov 02, 2009
I've read a lot of bad things about soy products. It's espcially bad for children and people with thyroid problems. I even found out that some vitamin companies as well as frozen foods have soy products in them.
bensmom09 says: on Nov 07, 2009
I don't eat a lot of soy products, but have always viewed it as a healthful substitute for meat. It's interesting to know that it suppresses thyroid function since I have hypothyroidism and was not aware that there was a connection.
frogqueen75 says: on Nov 09, 2009
I'm a migraine sufferer & an epileptic. When I started having seizures again after being very well controlled for several years, my neurologist asked if I'd made any dietary changes & I told her we were using soy milk/soy products more, since my toddler has a milk intolerance (I also do, but I just avoid dairy when it bothers me.) My neurologist FREAKED OUT & said that soy can cause major problems for women who have migraines, epilepsy, and other neurological problems due to its natural estrogen properties. What makes it worse for me is that I'm also in perimenopause (at the ripe old age of 33-and have been for at least 6 years) so my own hormones are "out of whack." I've been advised to avoid taking in any extra soy & that if I'm having trouble w/my own milk intolerance, to use rice or almond milk.
roo25hoo says: on Nov 09, 2009
Wow, I have just started to give my year-old twins soy milk . . . think I will stop giving it to them. It's not worth the risk if there are doubts about it.
cnarita says: on Nov 09, 2009
I drink a small glass of soy milk in the morning or I'll have it with cereal. When my daughter came home from college she liked it so much that she switched to drinking soy milk instead of milk. I do believe having everything in moderation but I also think that I may need to look into this a little more and decide if we need to stop all together.
jenanne says: on Nov 11, 2009
I've heard that too much soy can have a negative effect on males due to the female hormones that are in them. I've never tried it so I honestly do not know whether or not I would even like it.
monica74 says: on Nov 12, 2009
We occasionally eat soy, but it's soy nuggets, that you find in the mexican markets, it looks dehydrated. We usually make tacos, or ceviche out of it. Taste really good, and once hydrated looks kind of like ground beef. I tried this for the first time in Mexico, my sister in law made it, I thought she was playing at first, cause I never seen it before, but it taste really good! We don't eat it regularly, maybe once every 2 months.
giggles8589 says: on Nov 17, 2009
The only thing Ive ever had soy was milk and I love 8th continent chocolate milk and silks milk tastes okay too, dont know if I would try much more than soy milk.
Kailani96 says: on Nov 30, 2009
I actually found out the other day that I was allergic to soy, but this article made me realize that I'm not going to miss my bloating and gas or my herpes breakouts! I can't believe just how much this product has been hyped up to be.
tjshorty says: on Dec 03, 2009
I never was to fond of soy, I can see the benefits. When I was nursing my daughter and tried to give her formula she would have a reaction. A nurse suggested that I use soy formula while nursing. That worked. I also think that there is to much hype about it.
babsywabs says: on Jan 03, 2010
You folks that say "everything in moderation" crack me up. Is arsenic OK in moderation? Rat poison? While I'm not suggesting that soy equates to either of those two items, it IS poison for some. Many years ago I began to drink soy milk and eat a few soynuts for snacks, after watching an Oprah episode where some doctor was suggesting that soy was helpful for breast health. Yes, I used the soy in moderation - isn't a cup a day on my cereal moderate? Within several months I had developed a goiter and all the classic symptoms of hypothyroidism - always cold, weith gain, hair falling out, etc. I began treatment, and after reading some articles on the web, eliminated all the soy I knew about from my diet. I will be on treatment for the rest of my life. Soy is not the miracle that some want us to believe.
babsywabs says: on Jan 03, 2010
* weight, not weith
rileypark says: on Apr 03, 2010
Is all that proven by scientific studies? I don't know what to think anymore. I hear alot about the bad things regarding soy, hoever, my son is allergic to cows milk and was told to stay away from nuts. So that leaves out organic cows milk, almond milk and he's only 4 so he needs and wants his milk. What to do?
cupcakes4brkfst says: on Aug 23, 2010
you should put up a post about how bad cow's milk is for you! good thing almond milk is so yummy!! :)
To comment, please 
 or