Shespeaks Logo
BLOG CATEGORIES
All Things that Inspire Women Who Inspire Causes We Care About Health/Wellness Books We Love What's Going on At SheSpeaks?
Write Off the Extra Weight
Posted December 17, 2008

Here come the holidays, which means here come the cookies, cakes, and all other things decadently dangerous.  If you are worried about putting on extra pounds this season you may want to check out a new study recently published in the American Journal of Preventative Medicine. 

The new research has proven that people who keep diaries describing their daily food intake lost more weight than those who did not.  The study followed almost 1,700 overweight and obese adult men and women throughout the country.  All of the subjects were encouraged to limit their caloric intake, take part in weekly group sessions, exercise, and keep a food journal. 

The senior investigator of the study, Victor Stevens was recently featured in a Time Magazine article about the study.  He reported, “Hands down, the most successful weight-loss measure was keeping a record of what you eat.”

The study, which spanned a six-month period, showed that participants who kept a food diary between 6 and 7 days a week lost on average 18 pounds.  This was double what non-diary keepers lost.

The concept of losing more weight by keeping track of exactly what you ingest all day makes sense.  It can really make a person think about the amount of food they eat and whether most of it is actually good for them.  It can also make a person more conscious of the labels on the back of the package detailing the fat and cholesterol count.  And, at the end of the day you are well aware that you will have to face the truth staring back at you in that journal.  Stevens talks about how a person may think about eating that extra cookie “but you didn’t want it to show up on the diary at the end of the day.”

What do you think about keeping a food journal as a way to stay healthy?

Is this something you might consider trying to keep the extra holiday weight off?
 

36 Comments
Minni436 says: on Dec 17, 2008
Keeping a food diary is a good way to track what is being eaten. It is there in writing and cannot be denied. If you are trying to keep track in your head it is easy to forget about somethings. It is a good way to keep yourself honest.
am_i_lost says: on Dec 17, 2008
I've tried it before and it does work. But they are a lot or "work". You really have to stick to it like you would any diet. What I have found also really works for me with snacks is to get a small bowl or plate and just a few in it not take the whole box or bag along. I'm willing to try about anything to shed a few pounds...lol..and be healthy too!! Great!
natandcolesmom says: on Dec 17, 2008
I have found that keeping a food diary has helped me not only keep track of what I shouldn't be eating, but also the foods that I should be eating (dairy, vitamins, water, veggies, fruits, etc.).
jenndta says: on Dec 18, 2008
Keeping a diary does work. Three years ago, I lost about 75 pounds. I have managed to keep most of it off. Over the last year I have had two knee surgeries (one a complete replacement) so I gained I few pounds. For me, I have found if I just jot down quickly what I'm eating and how many calories the food is, I am dropping the weight again. It's easier when you actually know what your putting in your mouth. At the very least, you think twice before you eat something you should not eat. Good luck all and happy holidays...Watch the cookies, LOL
4roosters says: on Dec 18, 2008
This truly works. The hardest part is being honest with yourself and writing down every thing that goes into your mouth. It keeps you on track of what you should eat and how much naughty things you ate. I believe its OK to have a sinful snack now and then but this is a good way of telling yourself you had enough. In 3 months I lost 20 pounds.
sarahresch says: on Dec 18, 2008
fitday.com is a great site to keep track of your eating habits. it's a great accountability partner.
angelger28 says: on Dec 20, 2008
Writing it down doesn't work for me. I've put in the effort. I've been writing down what I eat for months and it doesn't stop me from returning to the kitchen. I go one step further and write my mood and times down as well. I'm a nursing mother and have a huge appetite but I don't need to eat as much as I do, I just feel famished all the time. I'm about 15 lbs overweight. It'll probably drop off when I wean my son. I hope so. I plan to continue to write in my food journal, it's become a habit. Maybe one day I'll figure out some self-control.
abigirl says: on Dec 22, 2008
I think writing is a good tool for weight loss. I have tried paper and pencil journals and a variety of online tools. I'm not sure which is the best for me. There was another study recently that showed people who took photos of their meals lost more weight than traditional written diaries. It seems that the underlying idea of either of these strategies is to pay attention to what you are eating and not just munch mindlessly.
ambulars says: on Dec 26, 2008
i really agree with, this . its all about accountably. the more the better.
MaurChclt says: on Dec 26, 2008
This is exactly what Weight Watchers recommends and has for years and it works!!
highlights says: on Dec 27, 2008
I think its really great to keep a food journal. It makes a person more aware of what you are actually eating. I think it would make you eat even healthier. I would definitely consider trying this.
jh0816 says: on Dec 27, 2008
I wonder if it is the writing of feelings (why you ate, what you were feeling, were you bored, etc.) that helps partly and I wonder if just writing period would help you eat less. I would think any kind of writing would be a good way to get out feelings instead of eating them away - like writing a novel or a diary/journal, something like that.
KrystalKF says: on Jan 01, 2009
Two years ago when I switched jobs from a very active to a very sedentary environment, I gained about 15 pounds. I kept a food diary while dieting and in two weeks I lost just about all of the weight. It is very tedious but if you can keep up with it I think it helps you stay conscious of your choices and intake.
joya03 says: on Jan 04, 2009
i tried keeping a food journal but it was to much of a hassel.I always forgat to record everything I ate.
ayesha16 says: on Jan 05, 2009
writing it never helps me because I always eat more than what I had expected to eat.
rockhound24 says: on Jan 09, 2009
I think that writing it down really works. It is a good way to be honest with yourself and erally figure out what you are eating.
texasmama says: on Jan 10, 2009
I tried so hard to keep a food diary but I could never remember to record everything. I decided to just exercise harder and try to be careful about what I ate because it was a huge hassle to write everything down. Especially the amounts because I am not good at estimating. My attempts did open my eyes to some of my food habits (like snacking while I make dinner and stress eating in the afternoon and evening).
clarkeb1984 says: on Jan 12, 2009
This does work for me! I think this is a great way to stay "honest" with yourself, but you have to be just that....honest. YOu also have to remember that if you are "cheating" on what you write down, you are only "Cheating" yourself out of weight loss potential.
nyprincess says: on Jan 12, 2009
I have kept a journal of how I felt, what I ate and what time it was. It was very helpful. I have lost over a hundred pounds. I can also look back on a week, month or year and see a history or improvements. I feel its encouraging.
rocketsummer17 says: on Jan 13, 2009
i agree that a food diary can be helpful...but you really need to stick to it for it to work
Texmel says: on Jan 17, 2009
What a great idea! I am writing this after the holidays---and I have a good 15 pounds that I would like to lose. I think I will try this! We are on a stricter budget now than ever before and I am keeping a list of all our expeditures weekly, which is amazing in helping us stay on budget. This will just be an easy addition to my list, a few pages over! (Yes, I am still using a day timer, not a Blackberry! :)
mscreneet says: on Jan 19, 2009
Food diaries are great.....remembering to enter the food that youve eaten into it is the problem. Every few month I say "im gonna try this again" It normally last about 2 weeks or so, than I fall off the ban wagon. This post just motivated me to give it another try!
proudtxmomof3 says: on Jan 19, 2009
Hmmm I will need to try this!
CaseyDeuce says: on Jan 22, 2009
I used a food journal once while dieting and I saw more success than when I didnt. But with 2 small kids its been really hard to me to attempt it again. I may try in the future to food journal!!
anu_p_pai says: on Jan 23, 2009
I just started to write a food diary and man it really helps , within a week i can make out the diff, eventhough i feel am eating less, but when i look at the diary am eating normally within my daily limit, and am feeling good about myself!!!
ppj927 says: on Jan 27, 2009
I guess if I kept a little notebook with me in a pocket or around my neck at home it would work for me. Otherwise I would forget those little quick bites that are my downfall.
slssrs1 says: on Feb 01, 2009
I did this when I was on weight watchers and it helped When I would look at all I ate in one day, I was surprised. My mother did it when she was working out with a personal trainer. it kept her from eating bad foods because she didn't want to get in trouble when she had to turn it in to her trainer.
salome says: on Feb 03, 2009
I'm sure it helps, but it's a little embarrasing to do in public when you're always eating lunch and dinner with your co-workers. If there were a cell-phone program on this, I woudl actually give it a go.
heavenlyhelper says: on Feb 04, 2009
Does your cell phone have a note section? If so...or em it to your email from your cell. I am going use the small notebook method ( mentioned) in my pocket or purse. Just a thought. I am willing to try all suggestions.
weezer05 says: on Feb 19, 2009
I've done this in the past and it really helped me. I could see what I needed to cut back on and what needed improvement.
ljamason says: on Mar 12, 2009
I have kept a food journal for the past two months and have lost 20lbs and 24inches...totally worth it!
grayce says: on Mar 26, 2009
My memory is so bad I can't keep up with a food diary. I need to though, it seems like it helps. I like the cell phone note section idea too!!
piscesgrly2 says: on May 30, 2009
I have an Ipod touch, which you can take notes on. It makes writing down what you eat, easy. I heard that people also lost weight by taking pictures of `what they ate with their phone.
aMUSEme says: on Jun 03, 2009
I've been a member of Weight Watchers for 2 years now and it highly emphasizes writing down everything. I lost 30lbs in 4 months and kept it off for a year. Then, I stopped writing things down and gained about 15lbs back. Now, I'm journaling like a maniac to get it back off!
JoyHappy says: on Jul 01, 2009
I am going to start a food diary right now. Starting today 7/1/09. Should i try to track calories too or just what i ate and drank? Let me know what anyone thinks about that. I have tried it before but then i give up on it on weekends or whatever when im home with my husband but its worth tring again.
summitqwestcomp says: on Dec 08, 2009
Keeping a food diary is a great idea! I keep track of mine at www.sparkpeople.com. It's a great, free, website that caters to your own personal goals. It even has detailed reports that allow for you too see exactly how you are doing based on different situations. I highly recommend it!!
To comment, please 
 or